[
  {
    "start": 3.0,
    "end": 15.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nThis should be the first choice, if it's just as reliable, but it's more sustainable and better value for money, we'd be nuts to do anything else, right? Even the vendors are like, \"Well, actually, we make quite good margin on this, at least as good if not better than selling the new product.\""
  },
  {
    "start": 15.0,
    "end": 41.0,
    "text": "Jingle:\nMy name is Patrick Hypscher, and this is circularity.fm, the podcast about understanding, building, and managing circular business models."
  },
  {
    "start": 41.0,
    "end": 78.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nYou are listening to the fifth and final episode of B2B Take Back. Last episode Julie Fournier and Kevin Chen showed how Legrand decides which of its 300,000 products gets which R strategy. Today we look at the other end of the loop. Take back only pays off if someone buys what comes back. You will find the one-page summary of this episode in our newsletter, together with the upcoming circular economy events around the world. Just sign up at www.circularity.fm."
  },
  {
    "start": 78.0,
    "end": 113.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nHe discovered Cisco's remanufacturing program in 2009 and built one of the first businesses focused entirely on it, taking it from zero to a million dollars in revenue within one year. That early trust with Cisco grew into Circularity First, where he now consults suppliers, customers, and governments on building circular marketplaces, including chairing one of the British Digital Sustainability Alliance's working group. He's put remanufactured equipment into aircraft carriers, hospital critical care units, and some of the world's largest banks. Welcome, Anthony."
  },
  {
    "start": 113.0,
    "end": 114.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nThank you, Patrick. Good to be here."
  },
  {
    "start": 114.0,
    "end": 120.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nAnthony, what is one product you personally would never return?"
  },
  {
    "start": 120.0,
    "end": 132.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nProduct I would never return. I'm extremely fond of my bicycles. I'm an avid cyclist and I have a, a couple of bikes that I really, really enjoy riding, and I will ride them until they fall apart."
  },
  {
    "start": 132.0,
    "end": 137.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nOkay. But I guess then you're also heavy, uh, like deep into repairing them?"
  },
  {
    "start": 137.0,
    "end": 173.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nExactly. In fact, I bought them secondhand. I've bought replacement parts also secondhand. There are a couple of things I have to consume on them, like tires and stuff you can't really, borrow from someone else after they've used them heavily. But, but yeah, no, I try and live all my life through, through the lens of the circular economy, including my hobbies. Okay. And did you ever have the o- opportunity to work with a, cycling company or, So yeah, there's a couple of, brands in the UK that specialize in reselling, used bicycles, even high-performance ones like mine. Yeah, I've worked with them to help kind of encourage others to go down that route, and take advantage of it to get better value for money and, and ultimately a better bike for, for their buck."
  },
  {
    "start": 173.0,
    "end": 184.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nWonderful, wonderful. Before we go too much into detail, let's start from the very beginning. Who is Circularity First and how did it grew out of Cisco Refresh?"
  },
  {
    "start": 184.0,
    "end": 333.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nGood question. Okay, so Circularity First really, is an organization that helps organization get better value from technology, and through that also improve their social and environmental impacts. So that's kind of the mission, how it started, as you mentioned, is way back in 2009, you know, we were looking to launch the business. We came across this program, Cisco Refresh, where Cisco were fully remanufacturing their own equipment. So they were taking the product back from the market. It could have been end of leases, could have been damaged product, could have been manufacturing overruns, a-any kind of source of the product. They brought it back through a full remanufacturing process to get it to as good as new. So they supplied it with the same warranties, same guarantees, crucially at lower cost. So you know, we saw this opportunity. No one else was focusing on it, so we kind of leapt on this chance to build a Cisco reseller specialized in that space. As you mentioned, it was quite successful. I think it even surprised Cisco how successful we were out of the gate. Really, we learned a huge amount over those first few years about what, you know, why people would buy remanufactured technology, under what scenarios, where they would use it, how they would use it. Over time, we realized there's obviously quite a big environmental benefit to that. It's always been close to my heart, but you know, we actually did some primary research to measure how much less carbon's involved in remanufacturing versus new manufacturing. We worked out how much of the materials were reused in that process. We then built tools to sha- illustrate that to others. Increasingly the sort of the case c- studies and the use cases expanded, and people started to ask us, \"Well, can you, can you help us about how we could do that too?\" You know, and whether that was inside of customers and organizations or even other vendors, we essentially got asked to start consulting, and we, you know, we're not naturally a consulting firm, but we'd, we've now got 18 years of experience in this market. We've learned a huge amount, and we've tried to make our advice really practical, linked to, you know, financial benefit. So we don't do sustainability just for sustainability's sake. As a business owner, I know what it takes to, to build a business in this space and that cash matters, and that you can have a business that's for profit, but also for good. So Circularity First emerged out of Cisco Refresh in terms of a dedicated partnership that expanded internationally, expanded kind of the kind of things that it did and what it offered customers. And increasingly we operate, with senior leaders in terms of how do you actually take the circular economy and use it to enhance the core fundamentals of your business, right down to baseline profitability, your brand, your, your employee, profile, everything."
  },
  {
    "start": 333.0,
    "end": 361.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nMm-hmm. Nice, wonderful, uh, story, and congratulations. If we go back to these early years, it sounds as if Cisco did have the remand process, but not so much the resell process, which brings me to two questions. First of all, why did Cisco start with the operations without having the demand, if I got that right? And, what made you, in this situation, step into that game and say, \"I believe there is a demand for that\"?"
  },
  {
    "start": 361.0,
    "end": 440.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nGreat question. Great question. Well, I think Cisco aren't unique in the fact that naturally they get quite a lot of products back. A lot of the big vendors have, capital leasing programs that naturally, at the end of those leases, often have product that come back. Equally, they have support programs, they have trial programs, they have all sorts of things that ultimately mean that they get quite a lot of their own technology back. Now, I think naturally you're gonna be thinking about, certainly if you're from a leasing side of point of view, well, how do I release that value? How do I get commercial value back for that? So I don't think it was a particular surprise to me that they had these programs, but I think what they did that was probably quite early was how they tried to position it and wrap it into a proper product that was designed for their channel. Which links to the reason why perhaps they hadn't spent a huge amount of time building the demand before is 'cause they believed that, you know, Cisco have an amazing channel program. Their channel partners is probably one of the most successful IT channel programs that's ever been, and I think they just felt naturally that they already had, channel partners out there that would probably focus on this and start selling it, but perhaps they'd underestimate how focused their other channel partners were on doing other things and being specialists in specific technology areas or obviously just selling brand new equipment. So, you know, I think, even without us, I'm sure they would've built the brand over time and got, and got some progress. But we like to believe we came in and helped them build the market, do some of the heavy lifting to really accelerate it."
  },
  {
    "start": 440.0,
    "end": 450.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nMm-hmm. And in hindsight, I guess it sounds easy to, let's say, sell the first million. When you're in there, it's super hard, I guess. What was so special about the early days?"
  },
  {
    "start": 450.0,
    "end": 533.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nI think timing did matter a bit. So this was 2009, right? So the world was in a deep sort of financial crisis. Not underestimate how important it was for organizations to get better value for money. And I'm sure that's equally true today. But, you know, when you're in the midst of a crisis, people still needed technology, and here was an option to get technology about 15% to 20% less with exactly the same guarantees, exactly the same warranties. And the only bit that was missing, and really where we had to do the heavy lift, was the education. Know, when, when you say things like refurbished or remanufactured to people, they have a preconception of what that looks like. Um, we often used to, you know, kind of almost get people to visualize it. I mean, if you think about an IP telephone, something really simple bits of technology that sits on your desk. If I say, \"Oh, I'm gonna give you a refurbished one,\" you might be thinking that the buttons are worn off or maybe there's even a bit of earwax around the headset. That's completely not the experience when you get something that's fully remanufactured, but that's part of the job of the salesperson, of the, the person e-educating someone about it, is to get them to see and feel and understand that differently, and that was very much part of our journey, is removing those biases, removing the perceived risks for people to, to acquire this technology and realize that over time they can deeply trust it and really bank that saving, you know, week on week, month on month, year on year, until it becomes a really meaningful, saving to their organization that they can redeploy elsewhere."
  },
  {
    "start": 533.0,
    "end": 539.5,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nHmm. Yeah back in the old days also, where I run a product as a service, we also experimented with the framing of pre-loved"
  },
  {
    "start": 539.5,
    "end": 540.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nHmm"
  },
  {
    "start": 540.0,
    "end": 571.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nTo overcome that. Yeah, because, these preconceptions, they're out there, and, you have to handle that. So now let's stick to the, let's say, demand for that. You need customers of course buy these products, and, you said Cisco's taking it back or took it back, and if we look beyond, Cisco Refresh, what are normally commercially sound destinations for taking back product? And why is it important to have this demand?"
  },
  {
    "start": 571.0,
    "end": 681.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nSo I think it's first useful to think about, taking back equipment that when it returns to the market, it could be in all sorts of different conditions. So there's a whole spectrum of different equipment that could come back and then be represented to the market. So, you know, Cisco was positioning this, this program right at the very, well, as close as is possible to new. So they really are everything that you got from a new product, you got from a, a refreshed device, including how you wrapped it into support contracts and, well, basically once it left Cisco, they treated it the same. Had a different part code, but it was treated the same. You know, all the way along to someone who might be selling something that's broken or for spare parts on eBay. So there's a quite a long spectrum there. But in our experience, there's, there is commercially sound reason, for all of the, those different grades of product to, to exist out there and can be useful in certain circumstances. So obviously at the extreme sort of far left for us, you know, we, as you mentioned, we've deployed on aircraft carriers and in critical care units in hospitals. Those are kind of literally life and death scenarios, and you need, you know, absolute trust that this technology is gonna be reliable, not just as it's installed, but for the length of its lifetime. But at the other end of the, of the spectrum, you have things that people might need for spares, that they might wanna take something apart and just get certain parts out of it. You might have organizations that literally have zero budget but would take something that works. We've donated technology to help rebuild schools in, in Ukraine. You know, it's pretty hard to, to say that's not a good idea. Obviously, it needs to work and it needs to be useful, but it doesn't need to have all the bells and whistles. They're not looking for a support contract. They're not l- looking for a five-year guarantee that it's gonna work. They just wanna give kids some connectivity back. So I think there's commercially sound reasons everywhere, but it's surprising it's still not actually as highly as adopted as you might think. So this, those misconceptions without being, peeled away still exist."
  },
  {
    "start": 681.0,
    "end": 703.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nAnd let's dig a bit deeper, into the commercially sound reasons. Do you have some hierarchy of, let's say, users, be it, this is an item you can resell right away, but you might need repair or refurbishment, are there some boxes you, look at, when you start thinking about, the take back and the users of the product or components and materials?"
  },
  {
    "start": 703.0,
    "end": 855.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nYeah. Good question. So, so as I said, we exist mostly on the kind of this side of the spectrum, the as-new environment, and for that people are expecting full manufacturer's warranty, like the same level of warranty. They're expecting to be able to put it in a support contract. They're expecting the brand, if we're talking about Cisco in this case, Cisco to be there if something goes wrong. And for that, you know, they would still be expecting a discount versus if they bought the equivalent product new, but you're talking a 15% to 20% discount, right? Which is a pretty meaningful discount if you're used to perhaps trying to negotiate a 1% or 2% reduction in cost year on year with your account team, right? So it's still a big saving. And, and in that category, as I said, I don't think there's anyone that couldn't use that technology. We've not had a single scenario, whether it's a global service provider, a stock exchange, you name it, That equipment is tried and tested in, in the most demanding environments on the planet. So can be used everywhere. Now, you know, when you get to kind of perhaps what I call the middle ground, there is a active, open secondary market for most technology, and depending on who you talk to, you kind of get different perceptions of this. You know, the vendors themselves, not a massive fan, and you can probably understand why. They're kind of competing against them, and they're kind of following their own rules, and they certainly have the, the pricing is kind of set more by demand and supply. But you might expect to get sort of 30% to 40% cheaper, than the brand-new product out of that secondary market, and they might provide a warranty. And for the most part, they're people running businesses that want to maintain their brand. They want to do a good job. It doesn't come with the vendor support. I probably couldn't comment on how reliable it is, but there's probably some risks involved in going down that path. But if you're, really budgetarily constrained, maybe you're a small mid-sized business, if the risks of inputting that's pretty low, like, well, I put an access point. If that access point, the point goes down and someone's going to send me a replacement, not the end of the world, but I can sort of save my budget by 30%, 40%. You might, you might decide that that's, that's something you might do. We do quite a bit of work into government. There's some really interesting things in some of the government rules and regulations where they want to use more non-new technology. But the problem is sometimes they go too far on that other side of the spectrum and they get burnt, and then that actually puts them off doing anything, and they just revert back to new. So look, it's a bit of a blended answer because it's not completely black and white. And in fact, they... a lot of people refer to the secondary market as the gray market. It's not illegal, but there are some risks. We've worked with people in that industry, and we understand, you know, that they're really trying to do the right thing and save customers money and deliver good service."
  },
  {
    "start": 855.0,
    "end": 867.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nRight. And if we now go beyond the product or let's say look at the components, uh, is this what you just said equally true for components and the condition of them?"
  },
  {
    "start": 867.0,
    "end": 928.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nYeah. So some vendors will sell you, components, but m- not many and not at scale. So the vast majority of vendors you can buy complete remanufactured products from themselves, but if you want spare parts outside of a normal kind of process, that's when you have to go to the open market. And again, you know, probably gotta do your research on who you're buying them from, what are the sources, what kind of warranties and guarantees they're gonna give you, and, you know, what are the risks of using, know, suppliers from somewhere else. In our industry, you always end up in a car analogy. You know, what... Are you talking to the original manufacturer? Are you talking to an approved, vendor or reseller who has service programs and stuff, or are you just talking to a kind of another garage or are you looking online and just hoping I'm getting the part that I, I'm really looking for? You know, there is a responsibility on the, on the buyer to be thoughtful about how you buy spare parts. In our world, particularly as we're just sort of working in networking, in data centers, and in security, it's actually a little bit less common to be buying spare parts."
  },
  {
    "start": 928.0,
    "end": 929.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nMm-hmm."
  },
  {
    "start": 929.0,
    "end": 954.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nIn the data center, people often, are often buying, additional capacity, so whether more CPUs or more memory, and then you have this whole debate around third party. So you might be buying brand new, but it might not be the original vendor stuff. Actually, it's a little bit less of the sort of spares part space than perhaps like laptops and things, where people are often buying keyboards, drives, memories, and things like that to kind of replace as they go. So it's not a heavily spare part-orientated marketplace."
  },
  {
    "start": 954.0,
    "end": 982.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nOkay. And to what degree is there already a closed loop when it comes to materials? So whenever you take back the products and you say, \"Well, I can't refurbish that, remand that an- anymore, and also the photo components, there's not no real commercially sound market. Can I at least recycle...\" Of course we have, we need to talk about metals, uh, and, and then plastics. Do these loops exist either as open loops or closed loops?"
  },
  {
    "start": 982.0,
    "end": 1061.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nSo yes, they do. Now obviously the best thing you can do is get the product returned to be able to use it exactly the way it was designed. So that's the highest value in the circular economy, right? But, but they do, it cascades all the way down and, and the vendor will take responsibility for some of that. So most of the vendors have trade-in programs, take-back programs and things like that, and they will try and return it to, to if, if it's got market value. So I sort of touched on donation a minute ago, is, is a really powerful way of ensuring things get used in the way that they were designed. Recycling does exist. Recycling of IT is, is limited. There are macro materials that are quite easy to extract, like some of the metals. Steel, for example, is still quite ubiquitous in, in routers and switches and things like that. And some of the, the, the, the micro, metals and minerals, there's some process for extraction of things like gold and, and, and some of the rare, metals. But everything in between, very good. So plastic's tricky. Certainly s- this, the ICUs and the circuit boards actually quite poisonous, quite tricky. So actually recycling isn't terribly good in our industry. It- they're trying to make it better, but, but particularly in the UK, m- a lot of that gets shipped abroad. Or they'll smash it up and they'll take out the, the easy stuff, and the rest of it gets shipped abroad to be processed. Honestly pretty messy. So we, we see recycling as the last resort."
  },
  {
    "start": 1061.0,
    "end": 1076.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nYeah, yeah. And now let's turn once again to the customer side. You mentioned frequently that there's the benefit, of some price reduction. Are there any other benefits, for the customers if they use, uh, reman, refurbed, products?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1076.0,
    "end": 1218.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nYeah. Actually there's quite a long list of, of benefits. So, so of course, yeah, there's that, that acquisition saving, but, sometimes also enabling people to extend the life of a platform, which is obviously very good from a financial point of view. So for example, in Cisco's world, they'll stop selling a product in their new line, but they will still sell it for another five years in, in, in the remanufactured line. So say you bought a product five years ago, you, you know, if you were gonna replace it with new or upgrade it with new after five years, that's kind of your timeframe. But instead of that, that whole platform only being available for five years, if you use remanufactured equipment to spare it, to increase the capacity, et cetera, you could extend that life up to 10 years. So doubling that, lifespan, you know, doubling that return on investment. So that's another, key benefit, and that was a fundamental part of some of the work we've done for the Ministry of Defence 'cause they like to stay on the same platforms. It's much better from a resilience point of view. They've, they've type approved it. They know how it works. They know how to support it. That, that's a big benefit. Obviously one of the big challenges we've got in the industry at the moment is, is, disruption in the supply chain. So a lot of people are struggling to even get the products that they need. And remanufactured is a separate supply chain, so it gives you a whole load of additional resilience through supply. You shorten your lead times, actually get you access to products that might, you might otherwise have to wait for a really long time for. And service providers particularly who are waiting to be able to install a device to be able to switch on their revenues, this is super important. So we do a lot of work with service providers to build them resilient supply using both new and things like remanufactured to make sure they can still deliver for their customers. So look, there's lots of sort of commercial benefits, you know, extending life, improving the supply chain, obviously that actual net reduction in, in cost. But you know, I talk a lot about sustainability too. Typically remanufactured equipment's about 60% less carbon in emission terms in the manufacturing process, so you can lower your carbon footprint by up to 60% without actually doing anything else. And IT is the fastest growing emissions stream. So for most companies, that's a really big win. If the organization cares about materials, the remanufacturing process typically reuses about 90% of the materials, so that massively reduces the footprint of extraction. And it's actually in the extraction part of the process when we're getting access to those metals and, and minerals you were talking about, where we do the most damage to nature. So when we're li- literally ripping up forests, damaging ecosystems and stuff. So, massive commercial benefits, also really significant environmental or social, impacts that can be improved by, by going down that route."
  },
  {
    "start": 1218.0,
    "end": 1236.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nWonderful. Despite all the benefits you just mentioned, you also early on said there are quite some concerns and, let's say misconceptions. So what are the recurring barriers, you need to overcome when you're selling and positioning such a proposition in the market?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1236.0,
    "end": 1258.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nWell, first off, it's, there's always gonna be a perception thing. You know, we've got to recognize that, IT is possibly one of the most critical things in an organization now, right? Like it or love it, but it's just a fact. Like none of us can operate without the technology that's in place, which means the kind of risk/reward, calculation for any IT leader is always gonna err towards risk adverse,"
  },
  {
    "start": 1258.0,
    "end": 1322.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nSo even though you might be offering commercial benefits, like, well, if that even increases my risk a little bit, should I really do that? My job is reliant on the fact that this network, this system, this software is working. You've got to recognize that, that, you know, these are the decision-makers, that you've got to help them overcome those perceptions of increased risk. So but that, that definitely still exists. And that requires quite a lot of things you c- you need to do to really get people confident that way, and I can talk about that more, some more. And there are some other sort of more subtle barriers that actually end up being quite impactful. So the IT vendors themselves, when they launch these programs, don't always launch them with, the sort of equivalent right-size incentives. So you could easily find yourself in a scenario working hand in hand with a vendor to sell a solution to a customer, and actually the salesperson on the, the vendor side to be disincentivized to, to offer a remanufactured solution, a bit crazy, right? But, but it could be part of their product set, part of the tools they use, but actually it's, you know, less incentivized to them."
  },
  {
    "start": 1322.0,
    "end": 1382.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nThey might go, \"Well, hang on a minute. If we're saving that customer 15, 20%, does that mean it's gonna be harder for me to retire my goal by 15 to 20%?\" You can see how that can cause some challenges, right? There's that. And then also, also, look, I've talked about supply chain challenges, like remanufactured isn't unli- unlimited supply. Nothing's unlimited supply, no matter what people tell you. But, but, you know, equally, there are supply chain challenges as well, which sometimes can make it difficult. And, know, if, if, if the vendor doesn't have ways of, of, reserving that equipment, it can be a bit of a moving target. So you might be saying to a customer, \"Oh, I think we can supply, you know, 60, 70% of this solution through remanufactured,\" and then tomorrow that supply isn't available anymore, which makes it quite hard to kind of get them to agree to the deal and get, and to, to roll out that project. There's quite a lot of things that actually chip away at, you know, what sounds like an amazing business model, and that we should just be doing, doing all the time. So we've had to build kind of mechanisms and processes and, and education approaches that mitigate all of those kind of challenges."
  },
  {
    "start": 1382.0,
    "end": 1449.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nAnd you referred earlier to the fact that, customers kinda expect a certain discount for reman, products. Uh, however, at the same time, or, like, a couple of minutes later, you also said, well, but, but OEMs brands give a as good as new, uh, guarantee. They put it in a condition that is as good as new. And I mean, I remember talking to Hilti, like, two years ago where, where they also said, \"Well, if we reman parts of our, of our tools, the electronic components are the, let's say, most reliable ones.\" So if they don't break within the first months, yeah, they will last forever, and taking these components to a second life, uh, will have a higher expected lifetime for these specific components, so they're, they expect them to last even longer. So, uh, have you seen constellations where, you can get the same price for reman as you get from new or maybe even higher, or is this just, like, a theoretical question?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1449.0,
    "end": 1533.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nIt's not theoretical, and, you know, post-COVID when there were massive shortfalls in supply, and we're starting to see that same thing again in terms of supply, at some point, you know, the price goes up even though the vendors typically control the prices. At some point the price goes up. It's just simple demand and supply. And some pe- people really, really need it, price will go up. But I don't think that's as much about it being remanufactured, it's about demand and supply. The bit that is, is nuanced here is I think what we're really paying for in that discount, if you like, what that discount really reflects is the cost of, perceived cost of change. So for someone to be willing to kind of, even though we might agree there's zero risk, but the perceived risk of doing something new, it needs to have that kind of delta. And I, I honestly believe that percentage is, is not about or refurbishing. Would probably be the same if you were someone who was a staunch, user of a certain vendor, that you've always used a certain vendor and another vendor's coming in. I bet you that's kind of the delta you need for someone to go, \"Okay, maybe I should look at this.\" That's a big enough change that could have me bring, bring a material benefit that I can redeploy elsewhere or, or whatever that, that would make me think about it. I think that's more of a normal sort of psychological process of as humans, we don't change for 3%. Know, we won't change just for the sake of change. Needs to be material enough, and that point is the delta for being material enough."
  },
  {
    "start": 1533.0,
    "end": 1545.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nYeah, interesting perception. Let's come back to the other concerns, you mentioned. Are there any, let's say, hacks or tactics, uh, you can share to overcome these barriers?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1545.0,
    "end": 1775.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nIt's gonna sound a little bit like I don't sell tech and I sell, double glazing, one of the best things we found to remove that perception of quality is to literally get people to open a box, take it out, and see it for themselves. So literally, I gave you the, the example of a, an IP phone, like a, yeah, a desk telephone. We would literally go to meetings with customers and we'd do a broader, broader pitch, but later on we would literally give them a chance to... We'd ask them, \"So what's your expectation?\" And they'll chuckle and they'll maybe share a little bit about what they're thinking. And then you get them to look at the box. Box just looks like a new box. You get them to open the box. It's all packaged nicely, as you might imagine, with all the spares and all the accessories, and you get them to take it out of the box and look at it, and they go, \"Oh.\" And you can see immediately it's \"That's not what I expected,\" and, and, and that starts a process for them to think about it in a slightly different way. Beyond that, you know, when you get to the sort of real technical people, the people that's really gonna be responsible for this being reliant on, you imagine it's a, a core switch or a networking device, is actually get them to take it into their labs. \"Yeah, here you go. Go break it. Treat it like you would any type of proving anything else. Go test it. Go prove to yourself, that this is either not reliable or is reliable and come back and tell me.\" Right? And, and, and if you do those kind of things, you'll start people on a journey, and then they'll... You, you know, maybe you go, \"Well, let's deploy it somewhere you think is low risk.\" So as I said, access points or desk phones. If one, if one user goes down for a few minutes or, you know, if a few people have a, a little bit of effect, are they gonna worry about it? Now, I don't think they need to do any of those things because we've deployed this everywhere. But, you know, depending on how risk-averse they are, taking them through those kind of steps will get them to the point that they actually, they generally can trust it. Yeah, you've got to assume they're at point zero even if you know they could go straight to point three. And is this, like risk aversion, is this something that is tied to individuals, in the customer organization? That you can say, \"Well, the IT department is, uh, generally more risk-averse,\" or is this finance, or is this procurement? No, good question. So I think probably it is mostly those r-responsible for service uptime. So yeah, the IT groups or the equivalent, you know, network managers or whatever it is inside an organization. You know, procurement normally do what, what they're d- asked to do. So they, they will normally go and source the type of technology and in the condition that they've been asked to source, and they are largely incentivized by value for money. So the value for money bit's really attractive. So you might find procurement kind of saying, \"Well, it's interesting, but, know, I, I need to get, get it through those kind of hoops.\" No, no, we find senior finance people, once it's proven and everyone's happy that finance love it, because again, it's, it's great value for money i-in lots of different ways. You know, even at senior leadership table, they like to be able to talk about that they've made sustainable decisions that, that... And they can present that internally when they're talking about, potential new staff, that we're trying to be more sustainable, we're trying to be greener. So we find that actually once it's in and working, you can move quite quickly to kind of almost a, you know, remanufactured first kind of scenario. Well, this is great. Like, how do we do this more? And I know sometimes you bump into supplier, problems at that point or, you know, there's other things that show up that need to be managed at that point. But, you know, the whole reason why we call ourselves Circularity First is that actually that's our goal, is that this should, this should be the first choice, if it's just as reliable, but it's more sustainable and better value for money, we'd be nuts to do anything else, right? So, so Circularity First is, i- is literally that mindset and the goal we're trying to take everyone towards, because we don't really see any downside. I'm like, you know, even the vendors are like, \"Well, actually, we make quite good margin on this, at least as good if not better than selling the new product.\" So who's actually being harmed in this process? So, so look, I, I wouldn't like to paint the picture that it's done. There's still these challenges that exist, but, most people, once they've got their heads around it and it's working, very happy."
  },
  {
    "start": 1775.0,
    "end": 1787.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nYeah. And you mentioned the, sales reps, and their incentive, and maybe their, let's say, misincentive for reman products, how to overcome that?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1787.0,
    "end": 1821.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nOh, I've had this conversation a few times. I strongly believe the simplest thing that all the vendors could do is just true it up. If you're selling 1,000 switches to a customer and you're... you've got in your program either 1,000 remanufactured ones or 1,000 new ones, and as an organization, you make about the same amount of profit on selling those two scenarios, that you should just pay your salesperson the same amount of commission for doing so. So the simplest thing they could do is just true up to the equivalent as if they'd have sold it new. Now, that's probably not popular for a million reasons, but I've not seen any vendors be bold enough to do that yet."
  },
  {
    "start": 1821.0,
    "end": 1823.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nAnd the reasons not to do it are?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1823.0,
    "end": 1872.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nWell, there's change again, and like l- let's not underestimate how complicated it might be in a gigantic global, vendor to change those kind of processes, to change them, h- how it does the maths, how it calculates it. Not insurmountable, but again, all these remanufactured equipment programs are considerably smaller than their push it out brand new programs. And of course, they don't want anything that will kind of move the dial in the wrong direction on those things. So I think it's just, it's back to that kind of fear, change, education. So now we tackled, two barriers, but I feel like there's still resistance. Yeah, you can talk to the head, to the, to the heart, and of course you need the incentive, but, but, I feel it's not going fast enough. Are there any other barriers?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1872.0,
    "end": 1944.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nYeah. So I think there's a real of cultural barrier. So if you think about other aspects of your life, most people live in homes that have been renovated, right? They're not brand new. People aren't living in brand, brand new homes, and we're pretty happy with that, pretty comfortable with that. We- we are safe, we're warm, we trust it for our families. That's fine. I would say actually a lot of people happy to buy a, a used approved car, you know, happy to zip around down the motorway, the autobahn at high speeds, trusting that their family will be safe. There is something strange when we look at technology, and particularly when we go inside of organizations, that somehow all technology needs to be the newest, latest, and greatest brand new. And we don't, we don't think about it in the same way we would buying other really big assets like a house or a car. We suddenly think it must be, it must be treated differently, and I think that's, that's reflected in lots of things in the, in, in the corporate world. You know, we don't necessarily live life we live at home, and our perceptions, our understanding of what's right or best value at home when we walk into the organization. So I think there's some fundamental barriers there in our perception of technology in the workplace, that, that need to be overcome too."
  },
  {
    "start": 1944.0,
    "end": 1949.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nAnd is this something you can discuss explicitly with customers?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1949.0,
    "end": 2027.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nYeah, I use that same phraseology when I'm in the boardroom with people, and we used to have in one of our buildings actually, entire boardroom table and the, and the screen and, and all the materials around it were all, refurbished or remanufactured. And we tell people when they're in that room, I say, \"Would you like our office?\" They go, \"Oh, yes, very fancy. Yes, very nice. We love this boardroom table.\" And well, yeah, well this is all remanufactured as well. And they're like... And the first thing is like, why would you do that? Is the kind of first question you get. And it's like, well, same list as always, better value for money, better for the planet, you know, but it's part of our core principles. We're living our values. So yeah, there are things you can do to kind of address that. But you remember that is a, I think that is a social thing that like yeah, generally the vast majority of people think they need... Well, they also mix up two things. They mix up, want the latest technology. Their assumption is that must be new. Don't believe they can get the latest technology and it be remanufactured, which is not true at all. The vast amount of the technology we provide to our customers is exactly the technology that their technology teams expect. We've not convinced them to get an older one and an earlier version, a slower, less performant, with less functionality. No, no. It's exactly what they asked for, with exactly the same warranties, guarantees, performance, everything, just a lower price and a lower footprint."
  },
  {
    "start": 2027.0,
    "end": 2048.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nMm-hmm. Yeah. Still a lot to learn and to change. Anthony, my last question, is on the categories and industries beyond electronics. Yeah, we learned you're familiar with other industries. What are the categories and industries that are still waiting, to be served with more take-back and remand offerings?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2048.0,
    "end": 2072.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nWell, I mentioned cycling earlier. I did definitely think that cy- cy- cycling had a real explosion during COVID and after COVID. And, know, still a lot of people, they talk about new bike day, and new bike day is only ever a new bike. No one talks about new bike day as a secondhand bike. So look, I know that's a sort of a, a relatively small industry compared to tech and IT, but, it's really interesting how lots of different industries are moving at different paces. And obviously IT is actually quite far back compared to clothing,"
  },
  {
    "start": 2072.0,
    "end": 2078.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nwhich is, you know, almost forever y- people have been buying and selling used clothing, and that's quite a big thing right now."
  },
  {
    "start": 2078.0,
    "end": 2117.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nMy daughter is every day is on Vinted buying and selling clothes. That's pretty adopted. As I said, like housing and, and, and cars are very open markets for this. It's, it's, it's not even a question. You know, people don't... When you say, \"I'm getting a new home,\" they, their first question isn't, \"Is it a new one?\" like, \"Oh, what are you getting? Well, where is it? Where are you gonna live?\" And, and then the... So the, the, the it's not the question. I don't think there are that many industries further behind than IT, if I'm honest, because if you look to the total percentages of technology in the, corporate world, in the organizational world is actually purchased remanufactured, or refurbished, I think you'd find the percentages are, are pretty small, whereas you wouldn't say the same thing in most of those other industries."
  },
  {
    "start": 2117.0,
    "end": 2139.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nAnthony, my last question is kind of an invitation to turn it around. You've seen so many, products, companies, and industries, uh, but at the same time I'm pretty sure you're still, facing challenges in, existing processes and, and projects. So w- what is one of the challenge, you have right now and where you'd like to have some ideas from the audience?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2139.0,
    "end": 2246.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nSo, there's a really interesting when you're building a circular economy, you're literally taking that linear economy where taking things out, we're making stuff, using it and then disposing it, and you're forcing it back together, right? So the trickiest part of that seems to be bringing lots of different stakeholders together that aren't used to working together before, right? So customers become suppliers, you know, vendors have to operate in a position where they're not in control of the supply, and they don't know how to value things in, in terms of the market dynamics. I think, kind of things that are missing are repeatable models for sort of high value circularity marketplaces. So you've got the kind of consumer marketplaces I see a lot of, you know, we've got Back Market, Refurbed, eBay, even Amazon have their own processes. So, so consumers have quite a lot of options to, to buy non-new things, particularly non-new technology. But we've not really seen it in the, in the commercial world, in the, in the organizational world. So I, I think there's a real gap there for, for facilitators to build specialist businesses that, that crack the nut of this. So I've seen one sort of, for sort of pharmaceutical products pop up to help health- the healthcare industry. But yeah, apart from the, like the secondary market and the marketplace they exist in terms of the real sort of formalized high trust, marketplaces. I've not seen any of the vendors really do that, and I'm not sure they're well placed to do that. I think maybe they need... we need someone in your audience to say, \"Oh, well, we've got a solution here and, and all, all we need is to bolt on the suppliers, the customers, and the vendor, and the magic will happen.\" But I think, you know, there's digital tools, to, to create marketplace, high trust marketplaces that can have kind of vendor stamped approvals in them to, to create these circular flows, is, is missing. Now, you know, I'm sure all the vendors are trying to think about it, but I've s- not seen anyone build one yet."
  },
  {
    "start": 2246.0,
    "end": 2259.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nCool. Awesome. To everyone out there, if you wanna look in that direction and talk to someone who managed to get it in one year from zero to one million, uh, reach out to Anthony. Anthony, thanks for sharing your experience."
  },
  {
    "start": 2259.0,
    "end": 2264.0,
    "text": "Anthony Levy:\nA real pleasure. Thank you, Patrick."
  },
  {
    "start": 2264.0,
    "end": 2309.0,
    "text": "Patrick Hypscher:\nThat was the fifth and final episode of B2B Take Back. Thanks to Anthony for showing us how to create demand for what comes back. And of course, thanks to all the previous guests of this series, Antonio and Marcos, Thomas Maier, Thomas Fetting, and Julie and Kevin, for opening up how their take-back programs actually work. The one-page summaries of all five conversations are in our newsletter at www.circularity.fm, along with the circular economy events coming up around the world. Until the next series, best of luck in building profitable circular business models. And please don't forget, the most abundant renewable resource is your imagination."
  },
  {
    "start": 2309.0,
    "end": 2334.041,
    "text": "Jingle:\nMy name is Patrick Hypscher, and this is circularity.fm, the podcast about understanding, building, and managing circular business models."
  }
]