[
  {
    "start": 8.3,
    "end": 22.0,
    "text": "I left my undergrad degree and moved to Panama, a very small island in the middle of the Panama Canal where there were many tropical biologists studying everything above ground these huge chaotic tropical forests."
  },
  {
    "start": 22.56,
    "end": 24.5,
    "text": "but nobody was looking below our feet."
  },
  {
    "start": 26.86,
    "end": 32.08,
    "text": "And i started asking questions about what could give rise to such incredible ecosystems."
  },
  {
    "start": 35.98,
    "end": 43.24,
    "text": "Through my work with Spun, we worked with people all around the world to understand these micro-island networks in their own habitats."
  },
  {
    "start": 43.36,
    "end": 52.06,
    "text": "And I think that biggest challenge has really been for people to flip their perspectives and think about underground ecosystems as where life begins."
  },
  {
    "start": 53.02,
    "end": 57.52,
    "text": "It asks a very respectful question What is it like be you?"
  },
  {
    "start": 61.34,
    "end": 66.74,
    "text": "Welcome To CC The podcast Where You See What others see."
  },
  {
    "start": 80.94,
    "end": 88.48,
    "text": "Good morning, talking about... Hello?"
  },
  {
    "start": 90.32,
    "end": 90.56,
    "text": "Hello!"
  },
  {
    "start": 90.9,
    "end": 93.66,
    "text": "Can you hear me?"
  },
  {
    "start": 95.32,
    "end": 98.78,
    "text": "Ceci here…."
  },
  {
    "start": 98.86,
    "end": 99.52,
    "text": "Is anyone there?"
  },
  {
    "start": 102.02,
    "end": 102.82,
    "text": "My name is Ceci."
  },
  {
    "start": 103.24,
    "end": 108.88,
    "text": "I'm based in Berlin and i want to welcome you to Ceci the podcast where you see what other's see."
  },
  {
    "start": 109.78,
    "end": 118.26,
    "text": "This season it all about The Mind And today we step into a hidden world beneath our feet."
  },
  {
    "start": 118.96,
    "end": 130.62,
    "text": "We'll explore the vast fungal networks that link plants and trees into a living web where information flows, resources are traded... ...and strategic decisions emerge without a brain."
  },
  {
    "start": 131.299,
    "end": 133.28,
    "text": "And guess with whom we will be talking!"
  },
  {
    "start": 135.299,
    "end": 160.179,
    "text": "Our guest today is evolutionary biologist Tobi Kiers University Research Chair & Professor of Evolutionary Biology at Freie Universität Amsterdam whose groundbreaking research draws on economic and evolutionary theory to understand how non-cognitive organisms, such as fungal networks process information... ...to strategically move resources…."
  },
  {
    "start": 160.399,
    "end": 161.76,
    "text": "…as they trade with plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 162.98,
    "end": 181.399,
    "text": "As she graciously showcased in her TED Talk titled Lesson from Fungi On Markets And Economics, Kiers explains how – like us– mycorrhizal fungi that live in plant & tree roots engage in strategic trading theft, and the withholding of resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 182.119,
    "end": 188.04,
    "text": "Remarkably displaying a capacity to be opportunistic – sometimes even ruthless!"
  },
  {
    "start": 188.619,
    "end": 191.739,
    "text": "And the challenges they faced due to inequality of"
  },
  {
    "start": 191.82,
    "end": 192.48,
    "text": "resources.\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 193.72,
    "end": 203.38,
    "text": "Toby Kears is co-founder for The Society For The Protection Of Underground Networks, SPUN where she serves as Chief Scientist & Executive Director."
  },
  {
    "start": 204.019,
    "end": 213.339,
    "text": "through SPUN She leads global efforts to map and protect the vast fungal networks that sustain ecosystems, and store carbon in Earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 213.88,
    "end": 217.559,
    "text": "Revealing the intricate biological economies beneath our"
  },
  {
    "start": 217.66,
    "end": 217.94,
    "text": "feet..."
  },
  {
    "start": 218.339,
    "end": 220.2,
    "text": "...that are essential for life on earth!"
  },
  {
    "start": 221.399,
    "end": 241.0,
    "text": "Her pioneering research has earned her many honours including a MacArthur Genius Award The Climate Breakthrough Award of twenty-twenty five Spinoza Prize Amodo Unfettered Science Award EO Wilson Award for Natural History and the Amsterdam Science Innovation Impact Award."
  },
  {
    "start": 241.899,
    "end": 251.22,
    "text": "She's also been featured in Time One Hundred Next, listed among The Explorers Club fifty... ...and recognized as a Smithsonian Magazine innovator to watch!"
  },
  {
    "start": 252.32,
    "end": 267.14,
    "text": "Through storytelling & scientific rigor she invites us explore the dynamic and complex subterranean world where organisms have been evolving sophisticated trade strategies for hundreds of millions of years."
  },
  {
    "start": 273.14,
    "end": 289.6,
    "text": "And to that wonderful introduction, one more wine because Professor Kiers has just been named the twenty-sixth Tyler Prize Laureate – The John and Alice Tyler Prize For Environmental Achievement often described as the Oscars Of The Environmental World."
  },
  {
    "start": 291.08,
    "end": 293.12,
    "text": "Thank you so much for being here today!"
  },
  {
    "start": 293.22,
    "end": 297.68,
    "text": "Professor Kier's Rockstar Scientist of the fungi scene Welcome."
  },
  {
    "start": 298.2,
    "end": 299.36,
    "text": "It is such an honor be hear."
  },
  {
    "start": 300.34,
    "end": 307.02,
    "text": "We often look up at the stars to find wonder, yet hidden universes exist right here on Earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 307.5,
    "end": 318.74,
    "text": "The depths of the ocean, shifting layers in the atmosphere and a delicate shimmering web of micro-risal fungi connecting roots like galaxies beneath our feet."
  },
  {
    "start": 319.46,
    "end": 326.1,
    "text": "Professor Kiers when and what first drew you explore these underground fungal networks?"
  },
  {
    "start": 326.86,
    "end": 329.26,
    "text": "Well, life is literally buzzing under our feet."
  },
  {
    "start": 329.74,
    "end": 344.72,
    "text": "I don't think that people realize about fifty-nine percent of all species on Earth live underground and so i became interested when I was quite young actually around nineteen years old And wanted to be a field biologist."
  },
  {
    "start": 345.7,
    "end": 360.04,
    "text": "So I left my undergrad degree and moved to Panama To very small island in the middle of the Panama Canal where there were many tropical biologists studying everything above ground, these huge chaotic tropical forests."
  },
  {
    "start": 360.58,
    "end": 368.72,
    "text": "But nobody was looking below our feet and I started asking questions about what could give rise to such incredible ecosystems above-ground."
  },
  {
    "start": 369.2,
    "end": 379.82,
    "text": "So before we go any further it's worth remembering something remarkable Fungia are far older than plants And without them, plants might never have made it onto land at all."
  },
  {
    "start": 380.56,
    "end": 384.56,
    "text": "In a sense, fungi are the original architects of life on Earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 385.2,
    "end": 386.28,
    "text": "Reflecting on this…."
  },
  {
    "start": 386.82,
    "end": 389.08,
    "text": "One our guests in these series Dr."
  },
  {
    "start": 389.28,
    "end": 396.48,
    "text": "Evan Alexander – A former Harvard neurosurgeon whose profound near-death experience reshaped his understanding."
  },
  {
    "start": 409.38,
    "end": 423.4,
    "text": "Over half a billion years ago, the Cambrian explosion sparked an extraordinary burst of evolutionary innovation during which most major animal groups first appeared and life on Earth suddenly became far more diverse and complex."
  },
  {
    "start": 424.26,
    "end": 431.58,
    "text": "As an evolutionary biologist what is your understanding of the underlying reason that caused that rapid evolutionary expansion?"
  },
  {
    "start": 435.18,
    "end": 436.12,
    "text": "It's great question."
  },
  {
    "start": 436.3,
    "end": 438.12,
    "text": "I mean evolutionary partnerships."
  },
  {
    "start": 438.7,
    "end": 448.84,
    "text": "they really underlie Life On Earth No organisms across the tree of life, they form these symbiotic partnerships for metabolism and protection and resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 449.62,
    "end": 463.64,
    "text": "And these partnerships involve what we call symbionts —and they allow hosts to live in habitats that they'd otherwise be excluded from— really get inaccessible nutrients and even capture very novel forms of"
  },
  {
    "start": 463.78,
    "end": 464.12,
    "text": "energy.\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 465.12,
    "end": 475.76,
    "text": "And so I think when we talk about rapid evolutionary expansion, We need to understand these partnerships and really understand When hosts evolve really extreme dependence on each other."
  },
  {
    "start": 477.0,
    "end": 481.22,
    "text": "This can sort of change the whole trajectory of evolution."
  },
  {
    "start": 481.96,
    "end": 485.78,
    "text": "And so if we think about plants and mycorrhizal fungi, for example."
  },
  {
    "start": 486.44,
    "end": 501.0,
    "text": "We know that about four hundred fifty million years ago the first partnership between plants in an aquatic environment living in water... ...and the ancestors of mycorhizae began to form partnerships!"
  },
  {
    "start": 501.82,
    "end": 511.4,
    "text": "That allowed plants to start colonizing land as The fungi started eating rock and transferring those resources to their algal partners."
  },
  {
    "start": 512.059,
    "end": 520.059,
    "text": "And in return, of course the algae were photosynthesizing and taking carbon out of the environment and feeding it to their fungal partners."
  },
  {
    "start": 520.78,
    "end": 524.339,
    "text": "that really gave rise to the ecosystems we live today."
  },
  {
    "start": 524.699,
    "end": 535.8,
    "text": "so trying Breakdown the formation of symbiotic partnerships is definitely key to understanding rapid evolutionary expansion."
  },
  {
    "start": 537.04,
    "end": 548.76,
    "text": "And when we talk about bioassemblies beneath our feet, the idea of networks naturally brings to mind that interconnectedness of relationships and in ecology evolution."
  },
  {
    "start": 548.839,
    "end": 557.459,
    "text": "on biodiversity as you were mentioning Our attention is of course symbiosis."
  },
  {
    "start": 558.26,
    "end": 566.62,
    "text": "Up next, we will hear from one of the leading thinkers at The Crossroads of Literature Science and Technology Professor Catherine Hales."
  },
  {
    "start": 567.079,
    "end": 574.8,
    "text": "she is Distinguished Research professor At the University Of California Los Angeles And James B Duke Professor Emerita at Duke university."
  },
  {
    "start": 576.18,
    "end": 581.459,
    "text": "She will introduce us to the concept of symbiosis and its role in evolutionary history."
  },
  {
    "start": 585.86,
    "end": 608.199,
    "text": "This idea really builds upon the work of Lynn Margolis, very distinguished biologist who really revolutionized The evolutionary picture Of how dynamics were by arguing that the main driver of evolution is not natural selection as Darwin suggested but rather symbiosis."
  },
  {
    "start": 608.86,
    "end": 627.099,
    "text": "and she did some astonishing pioneering Work in being able to prove that the emergence of eukaryotic cells, that is, cells that can use oxygen in fact occurred through an act of endosymbiosis."
  },
  {
    "start": 627.68,
    "end": 638.199,
    "text": "when one prokaryotic species invaded another didn't die completely but rather became the mitochondria-the energy producing part a cell."
  },
  {
    "start": 638.699,
    "end": 646.28,
    "text": "And this was confirmed as it was discovered to be different from the DNA of the nucleus."
  },
  {
    "start": 646.939,
    "end": 657.959,
    "text": "So they are two different species now living together as a single organism, and the word that Margolis uses to describe it is endosymbiosis."
  },
  {
    "start": 663.839,
    "end": 670.839,
    "text": "When you work on relationships between plants roots and fungi how do you define symbiosis?"
  },
  {
    "start": 670.939,
    "end": 674.86,
    "text": "And How Is It Different from Mutualism & Corporation?"
  },
  {
    "start": 675.62,
    "end": 681.939,
    "text": "Well, the really classic definition of symbiosis is just defined by two species living very intimately together."
  },
  {
    "start": 682.76,
    "end": 697.4,
    "text": "So in a fact this could actually be negative as in paratysism where one partner is gaining resources from other or positive as in mutualism when both partners are benefiting from interaction."
  },
  {
    "start": 697.819,
    "end": 708.86,
    "text": "but symbiosis has been an idea to live intimately Mutualistic partnerships where both partners tend to benefit, they really underlie life on our planet."
  },
  {
    "start": 709.439,
    "end": 721.04,
    "text": "We know that evolution of Life On Earth has been driven by these very small number major evolutionary transitions and those have been characterized as we just heard by endosymbiosis."
  },
  {
    "start": 721.14,
    "end": 731.079,
    "text": "were individuals previously replicated independently all of a sudden they cooperate to form a new, more complex lifeform."
  },
  {
    "start": 731.339,
    "end": 739.78,
    "text": "So we heard about archaea and eubacteria forming eukaryotic cells in multicellular organisms And our own mitochondria are great examples."
  },
  {
    "start": 740.42,
    "end": 746.8,
    "text": "We don't think of them as other organisms living inside us Instead...we think that is our own organelles."
  },
  {
    "start": 747.38,
    "end": 748.66,
    "text": "It's the same thing with insects."
  },
  {
    "start": 748.74,
    "end": 753.9,
    "text": "They have endosymbiotic bacteria That also sort considered organelles."
  },
  {
    "start": 754.719,
    "end": 761.42,
    "text": "But what we need to think about, and again this is not a question of Is it natural selection or symbiosis?"
  },
  {
    "start": 761.74,
    "end": 771.62,
    "text": "There's both things operating because Not all cooperative partnerships are en route To the sort of transition to a major evolutionary shift."
  },
  {
    "start": 772.219,
    "end": 777.52,
    "text": "It actually requires very strict conditions The partner interests Of two partners."
  },
  {
    "start": 777.579,
    "end": 780.479,
    "text": "they really Need be aligned And benefits."
  },
  {
    "start": 781.76,
    "end": 793.079,
    "text": "what you call integrated cooperation has to lead really intense mutual dependence, so again if we look at something like plants and fungi they have their own interests."
  },
  {
    "start": 793.599,
    "end": 807.38,
    "text": "And there are times when these interest almost perfectly aligned but also attention especially when there's, let's say multiple partners interacting simultaneously creating what we call a tragedy of the commons."
  },
  {
    "start": 807.88,
    "end": 820.06,
    "text": "So it is not that all symbioses lead to major evolutionary transitions and natural selection is just the process underlying what partners benefit under certain conditions."
  },
  {
    "start": 821.0,
    "end": 835.939,
    "text": "Well now lets hear a fascinating example of dolphins... ...and humans working together shared by inaugural Endowed Professor for Nature and Humanity at Stony Brook University, founder of the Safina Center."
  },
  {
    "start": 836.16,
    "end": 837.219,
    "text": "Ecologist Dr."
  },
  {
    "start": 837.339,
    "end": 837.959,
    "text": "Carl Safina."
  },
  {
    "start": 839.54,
    "end": 856.92,
    "text": "The dolphins in the humans have somehow figured out that the dolphins can find fish push them near a shore where they can throw nets but inevitably some fish only get injured and don't get caught in."
  },
  {
    "start": 856.979,
    "end": 859.52,
    "text": "the dolphins can easily catch the injured fish."
  },
  {
    "start": 860.12,
    "end": 871.38,
    "text": "In some cases, the fishermen will throw the dolphin some fish... ...and this is an inter-species cooperative thing which obviously involves both of them really thinking at the exact same level about what's going on."
  },
  {
    "start": 873.579,
    "end": 878.459,
    "text": "Professor Cures you talk about cooperation and tensions happening."
  },
  {
    "start": 879.28,
    "end": 884.74,
    "text": "So if dolphins and humans can team up in a mutualistic cooperation, what about fungi?"
  },
  {
    "start": 884.939,
    "end": 885.62,
    "text": "And plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 885.719,
    "end": 888.8,
    "text": "What kind of relationship do they have?"
  },
  {
    "start": 889.36,
    "end": 898.28,
    "text": "well we really have to think About the driving force for entering in a Mutualistic Relationship and that is there should be some benefit And it makes sense."
  },
  {
    "start": 898.38,
    "end": 904.3,
    "text": "actually outsourcing a capability to another partner is an incredible tactic, right?"
  },
  {
    "start": 904.339,
    "end": 906.14,
    "text": "We can't specialize in everything."
  },
  {
    "start": 906.719,
    "end": 908.18,
    "text": "So... It's nice!"
  },
  {
    "start": 908.339,
    "end": 923.78,
    "text": "It's better sometimes work with the partner that has unique trait and specialized in let say accessing new form of food or energy protecting against certain pathogens But we also need to think about when this can be dangerous."
  },
  {
    "start": 924.24,
    "end": 937.319,
    "text": "We once wrote a piece called Welcome To Symbiont Prison that explores the idea, there's kind of unjust side sometimes in symbiosis and one partner really remains in control."
  },
  {
    "start": 938.12,
    "end": 943.4,
    "text": "but I'd say tension actually creates novelty drives innovation."
  },
  {
    "start": 944.02,
    "end": 958.459,
    "text": "So you're always going to have this inherent tension in mutualisms, even as you do between the humans and dolphins where the dolphins are actually wanting more fish than they get And you can kind of call it like a reciprocal exploitation."
  },
  {
    "start": 959.02,
    "end": 969.62,
    "text": "You're always evolving strategies to try and get more resources, in this way I think cheating is the real driver for innovation – it's more common than people imagine!"
  },
  {
    "start": 970.199,
    "end": 979.76,
    "text": "One system that worked with my PhD was between legumes—so bean plants —in this case soybean plant—and rhizobia."
  },
  {
    "start": 980.4,
    "end": 984.599,
    "text": "And rhizobia are a bacteria that fix nitrogen from the atmosphere."
  },
  {
    "start": 984.719,
    "end": 988.78,
    "text": "So they actually take, those small amount of nitrogen we have in our atmosphere."
  },
  {
    "start": 989.36,
    "end": 991.56,
    "text": "and there is way breaking this triple bond."
  },
  {
    "start": 991.64,
    "end": 992.819,
    "text": "it's very hard to break."
  },
  {
    "start": 993.42,
    "end": 999.14,
    "text": "They do these in root systems and specialized cells on the root system of soybean plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 999.8,
    "end": 1003.36,
    "text": "so the rhizobia feeding nitrogen made by air."
  },
  {
    "start": 1003.459,
    "end": 1010.199,
    "text": "It's an incredible symbiosis with legumes and in return the legumes give them carbohydrates, sugars."
  },
  {
    "start": 1010.54,
    "end": 1013.56,
    "text": "Was this not an article published In Nature?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1013.979,
    "end": 1015.199,
    "text": "I have it with me right now!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1015.78,
    "end": 1015.839,
    "text": "Oh"
  },
  {
    "start": 1015.959,
    "end": 1026.079,
    "text": "wonderful yes so This is my PhD work published in nature in two thousand three And we were interested in why rhizobia keep fixing that nitrogen."
  },
  {
    "start": 1026.18,
    "end": 1028.12,
    "text": "It's quite expensive for them to do."
  },
  {
    "start": 1028.22,
    "end": 1031.02,
    "text": "That takes lots of energy To break that triple bond."
  },
  {
    "start": 1031.64,
    "end": 1033.82,
    "text": "There was a big question in evolutionary theory."
  },
  {
    "start": 1034.58,
    "end": 1049.66,
    "text": "If you're a rhizobia on a root system that's colonized by many other different competitors of Rhizobia and y'all getting the same amount of sugars, why would you spend all your energy being just good team player?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1050.28,
    "end": 1059.42,
    "text": "if it pays to defect and actually be a free rider while all the other rhizobia on the root system are fixing nitrogen."
  },
  {
    "start": 1060.42,
    "end": 1071.78,
    "text": "So we did this experiment where we actually forced the rhizopia to cheat, now that sounds like it would be hard but what you did was we actually grew the rhizobia in an argon atmosphere."
  },
  {
    "start": 1072.24,
    "end": 1083.18,
    "text": "so rather than a nitrogen atmosphere we grew them into another inert gas which is just argon and of course the rhizobia in an individual nodule, they were not actually allowed to fix nitrogen."
  },
  {
    "start": 1083.26,
    "end": 1084.3,
    "text": "And so then we watched."
  },
  {
    "start": 1084.92,
    "end": 1088.12,
    "text": "could the legume detect when it was being cheated?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1090.28,
    "end": 1101.86,
    "text": "And so when we put them in this argon atmosphere, We realized through a whole series of sort-of complicated experiments that the legume was actually suffocating those bacteria That failed to produce nitrogen."
  },
  {
    "start": 1101.96,
    "end": 1110.92,
    "text": "So somehow it could sense at The level of the individual nodule When It Was getting cheated and responded by By Actually Suffocating Those Bacteria."
  },
  {
    "start": 1111.92,
    "end": 1114.44,
    "text": "And I think that this is, it's an interesting idea."
  },
  {
    "start": 1114.7,
    "end": 1114.88,
    "text": "You know?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1114.96,
    "end": 1124.18,
    "text": "This idea... That the tension exists in partnerships but really allows for exploration of all kinds new strategies and traits."
  },
  {
    "start": 1124.32,
    "end": 1128.46,
    "text": "It leads to many times a beautiful evolutionary arms race."
  },
  {
    "start": 1134.76,
    "end": 1147.98,
    "text": "What would you say is most important treat or drive For individual to enter into a mutualistic relationship be maybe the capacity to increase their reproductive success."
  },
  {
    "start": 1148.74,
    "end": 1149.36,
    "text": "Yeah, exactly."
  },
  {
    "start": 1149.52,
    "end": 1160.22,
    "text": "I mean so when you're entering into a mutualistic relationship it's about gaining more resources while paying less costs and usually that has to do with them being able to reproduce."
  },
  {
    "start": 1160.28,
    "end": 1166.96,
    "text": "You need those resources to reproduce And obviously there is very strong drive for reproduction in evolutionary biology."
  },
  {
    "start": 1167.54,
    "end": 1169.24,
    "text": "So thats something we look at."
  },
  {
    "start": 1169.9,
    "end": 1172.14,
    "text": "Those resources can be all kinds of resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 1172.22,
    "end": 1185.32,
    "text": "It doesn't necessarily have to be food or protection Or space but what it leads to is really interesting partnerships that evolve basically everywhere we look."
  },
  {
    "start": 1186.14,
    "end": 1191.6,
    "text": "It's striking how many parallels they are with the way humans build up our own economies."
  },
  {
    "start": 1192.06,
    "end": 1201.0,
    "text": "I mean, its same logic of maximizing resources while minimizing costs and... The same instinct to secure space protection?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1201.7,
    "end": 1203.46,
    "text": "I don't know..the conditions to thrive?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1203.86,
    "end": 1204.54,
    "text": "Its all there!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1204.72,
    "end": 1205.64,
    "text": "Yes exactly"
  },
  {
    "start": 1225.22,
    "end": 1232.22,
    "text": "Thinking about how nature is driven by reproductive success, while in markets it's driven by profit."
  },
  {
    "start": 1232.64,
    "end": 1240.48,
    "text": "That tension that pushed to do better seems connected to the way you compare biological exchanges with economic ones."
  },
  {
    "start": 1241.18,
    "end": 1242.12,
    "text": "was there a moment?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1242.32,
    "end": 1258.26,
    "text": "In the field or in the lab when you realize these fungal networks were far more strategic than we thought and could give us Perhaps a couple of simple examples on how different species interact in these networks and what they gain from each other."
  },
  {
    "start": 1258.64,
    "end": 1263.46,
    "text": "I mean, you've been already talking about that but maybe another specific example?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1264.14,
    "end": 1264.56,
    "text": "Of course!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1264.64,
    "end": 1272.92,
    "text": "So the relationship between plants and mycorrhizal fungi is little bit different than one i just explained about nitrogen fixing bacteria."
  },
  {
    "start": 1273.92,
    "end": 1283.26,
    "text": "And why that is, because these mycorrhizal networks they form networks and what that means Is That They Can Interact With Multiple Partners Simultaneously."
  },
  {
    "start": 1284.1,
    "end": 1305.6,
    "text": "So Where You Think Of A Bacteria Almost Being Enslaved By The Legume Itself Inside the Nodule When a plant interacts with Mycorrhizo Fungi really understand the exchange of resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 1306.18,
    "end": 1318.68,
    "text": "So what a plant is doing, it's taking CO₂ out of the atmosphere via photosynthesis and its turning that carbon into form that can feed directly to mycorrhizal fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 1319.62,
    "end": 1325.12,
    "text": "Now this carbon goes down through root system then enters in network itself."
  },
  {
    "start": 1326.56,
    "end": 1330.78,
    "text": "Mycorrhizal fungi we study, they are completely dependent on the plant for all of their carbon."
  },
  {
    "start": 1331.14,
    "end": 1334.4,
    "text": "They're not getting it from the environment—they're only getting fed from plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 1334.44,
    "end": 1339.82,
    "text": "so that creates a really like an obligate dependence on trade for these resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 1340.8,
    "end": 1354.34,
    "text": "They use the carbon to build this very complex networks underground and in return... ...the fungi are foraging for other resources such as phosphorus or nitrogen which then collect into the network feed up onto the plant"
  },
  {
    "start": 1354.42,
    "end": 1354.58,
    "text": "root."
  },
  {
    "start": 1355.04,
    "end": 1361.8,
    "text": "Now again, what's important about this particular relationship is that it's what we call a bipartite network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1362.02,
    "end": 1369.4,
    "text": "That's a big word but basically only means an individual plant can interact with multiple strains of fungi simultaneously."
  },
  {
    "start": 1370.06,
    "end": 1374.3,
    "text": "so they choose which one to allocate its resources too."
  },
  {
    "start": 1375.12,
    "end": 1379.54,
    "text": "at the same time an individual fungi can interact with multiple plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 1380.2,
    "end": 1388.8,
    "text": "And so what this does is that it means both sides of the relationship, there's a choice about where to send those resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 1389.42,
    "end": 1398.12,
    "text": "and we started looking at these plant fungal networks asking do they resemble sort-of economic markets?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1398.44,
    "end": 1399.52,
    "text": "I guess thats were."
  },
  {
    "start": 1400.64,
    "end": 1402.78,
    "text": "research became really interesting"
  },
  {
    "start": 1404.26,
    "end": 1408.12,
    "text": "Because there's so much complexity in these exchanges."
  },
  {
    "start": 1408.88,
    "end": 1417.34,
    "text": "And besides sugars, and I believe also fats you are also mentioning space and protection when it gets into roots for example."
  },
  {
    "start": 1418.12,
    "end": 1421.5,
    "text": "What other worth mentioning resources are exchanged?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1422.2,
    "end": 1429.84,
    "text": "Let say between plants and fungi and roots in this networks and which minerals are the most sought after in the underground markets?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1430.5,
    "end": 1431.48,
    "text": "Yeah good question."
  },
  {
    "start": 1432.28,
    "end": 1434.38,
    "text": "From the plant side of view, we know it's carbon."
  },
  {
    "start": 1434.54,
    "end": 1441.14,
    "text": "So they're sending carbon but in different forms again... ...of sugars and fats which is an incredible diet to live on for the fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 1442.02,
    "end": 1447.74,
    "text": "And this is still a field of research I would say Most people."
  },
  {
    "start": 1448.22,
    "end": 1462.0,
    "text": "at the initial when we first started studying it It was all about phosphorus But then we realized that nitrogen was also moving through networks In large amounts of nitrogen Also Some minerals that are more scarce."
  },
  {
    "start": 1462.5,
    "end": 1474.76,
    "text": "And now we don't know if the fungi are actually going out and mining those in particular, or they're coming into network because of other forms of resources that are mainly dominated by phosphorus and nitrogen."
  },
  {
    "start": 1475.62,
    "end": 1478.76,
    "text": "We also know water is incredibly important as a resource."
  },
  {
    "start": 1479.64,
    "end": 1487.04,
    "text": "These fungi can really help plants survive extreme drought conditions so it's an extremely important benefit."
  },
  {
    "start": 1488.86,
    "end": 1494.46,
    "text": "But there's other benefits, like we know that these plants that are colonized by migrazofungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 1495.08,
    "end": 1497.32,
    "text": "it also up regulates their defenses."
  },
  {
    "start": 1497.66,
    "end": 1501.34,
    "text": "Now this is a really hard service to study because its very diffuse."
  },
  {
    "start": 1501.38,
    "end": 1512.6,
    "text": "but what we know when the fungi actually colonize root then changes chemistry of plant leaves and protects them against certain pathogens or bivouery."
  },
  {
    "start": 1513.56,
    "end": 1518.52,
    "text": "We also know that the fungi are very good at protecting plants from heavy metals."
  },
  {
    "start": 1519.0,
    "end": 1523.32,
    "text": "That they actually can prevent them getting up into plant leaves."
  },
  {
    "start": 1523.84,
    "end": 1533.46,
    "text": "Microplastics is another avenue people look for, that fungi protect again upper part of a plant from accumulating microplastics."
  },
  {
    "start": 1534.06,
    "end": 1541.04,
    "text": "So these kinds things just starting to explore it might not be as clear carbon for phosphorus."
  },
  {
    "start": 1541.58,
    "end": 1550.7,
    "text": "This is amazing, and for all it takes us to other ways of thinking about the importance of fungi for ecology."
  },
  {
    "start": 1550.86,
    "end": 1558.62,
    "text": "And although destruction that we've been meeting with plastic and metals... ...and so on maybe… We would begin to trade with them!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1559.5,
    "end": 1563.38,
    "text": "About some ideas in how to free ourselves from those materials."
  },
  {
    "start": 1564.34,
    "end": 1577.5,
    "text": "You were talking at the beginning about aligning interests in these relationships And talking about the exchanges and ability to communicate, let's see Professor Hales introduce us to the concept of Umwelt."
  },
  {
    "start": 1578.26,
    "end": 1596.02,
    "text": "The different aspects that this concept brings about... An important element here is the idea of umwelt term from nineteenth-century biologist Jacob van Ukskul, and Uxkul's idea was simple and brilliant."
  },
  {
    "start": 1596.54,
    "end": 1604.66,
    "text": "And that is each species constructs its own world dependent on it's neurological and physical capacities."
  },
  {
    "start": 1605.4,
    "end": 1608.98,
    "text": "so has a number of interesting implications."
  },
  {
    "start": 1609.18,
    "end": 1616.68,
    "text": "one which is humans do not sense reality any more than all the other species do."
  },
  {
    "start": 1617.36,
    "end": 1636.26,
    "text": "We sense reality as interpreted through human sensibilities, so we're always within a human umbelst—a word that means roughly World Horizon or World Surround And there's no way that we can escape it because, We always see with human eyes."
  },
  {
    "start": 1636.36,
    "end": 1637.88,
    "text": "We think with human brains."
  },
  {
    "start": 1638.5,
    "end": 1651.3,
    "text": "Now...we have enlarged our umbel through technologies like microscopes telescopes and so forth But in the last analysis all of that is always filtered Through a human brain."
  },
  {
    "start": 1651.82,
    "end": 1651.9,
    "text": "So"
  },
  {
    "start": 1652.26,
    "end": 1652.6,
    "text": "that's"
  },
  {
    "start": 1653.04,
    "end": 1660.02,
    "text": "one of the implications of the Umveld idea, and it is central to an integrated cognitive framework."
  },
  {
    "start": 1660.14,
    "end": 1668.26,
    "text": "Because in order for two species to communicate they have overlapping umveltings."
  },
  {
    "start": 1668.62,
    "end": 1675.86,
    "text": "so we communicate with dogs because We know that they see the squirrel, but we also see."
  },
  {
    "start": 1676.52,
    "end": 1681.5,
    "text": "and so uh...we can communicate through words or signals our body language about it."
  },
  {
    "start": 1681.98,
    "end": 1696.34,
    "text": "If there's no overlap between their own valve then communication is not possible although we have found a lot of artificial ways to begin to create those overlaps for example with the fungal networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 1702.74,
    "end": 1718.08,
    "text": "that could also be referred as an Umwelt overlapping example, as he correctly pointed out on how communication between humans and dolphins when fishing together and cooperating happens exactly at the same level of awareness."
  },
  {
    "start": 1718.76,
    "end": 1722.64,
    "text": "I mean just like there are communications happening between plants in Fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 1723.88,
    "end": 1727.78,
    "text": "You, Professor Kiers and your colleagues published a paper in Nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 1727.94,
    "end": 1737.54,
    "text": "And there was also a subsequent New York Times article about an incredible robot used... ...in the lab to track fungal decision-making."
  },
  {
    "start": 1738.18,
    "end": 1740.06,
    "text": "Could you tell us a bit about this robot?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1740.34,
    "end": 1749.14,
    "text": "Maybe share other tools that use sensor setups Anything that helps trace how carbon, phosphorus & resources move between fungi and plants?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1749.78,
    "end": 1756.78,
    "text": "Yeah, this is definitely one of my favorite topics to talk about because it asks a really respectful question I think."
  },
  {
    "start": 1756.86,
    "end": 1759.84,
    "text": "and that's the question what does like be you?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1760.56,
    "end": 1764.78,
    "text": "And we wanted to develop a way to ask that of these micro-ISL networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 1764.9,
    "end": 1766.16,
    "text": "What is it like, to be you?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1767.54,
    "end": 1788.58,
    "text": "Together with my colleague Professor Tom Shimizu who's a biophysicist at ELMOF which is the Biophysics Research Institute here in Amsterdam and very talented postdoc Loretto Oriete Galvez We spent years designing and building a custom designed robot that really does this high throughput, we call time-lapsing."
  },
  {
    "start": 1789.08,
    "end": 1807.98,
    "text": "That could track over half a million fungal nodes across space and time in these living networks that were attached to roots And so you can think of each one of those nodes as the decision point where the fungi either go left they go right or They form a bridge and fuse together?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1809.06,
    "end": 1824.24,
    "text": "What We're trying To do is understand how they navigate Space and then try to understand how they move resources, to be able to achieve this very efficient road system that they build underground."
  },
  {
    "start": 1824.9,
    "end": 1833.78,
    "text": "And so you can imagine this robot is taking these time-lapse images — we're tracking every node using complicated pipelines—to extract the structure of a network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1833.92,
    "end": 1844.88,
    "text": "but I think what makes it even more interesting points in time and space, we could actually measure the flows inside the network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1845.34,
    "end": 1848.94,
    "text": "Now these fungi are translucent which is very lucky for us!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1849.42,
    "end": 1853.44,
    "text": "And it allows this to measure these flow trajectories inside the networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 1853.5,
    "end": 1870.14,
    "text": "so again We measured about a hundred thousand of these cytoplasmic flow trajectory towards an away from root To really test how fungi optimized carbon movement what we call supply chain design challenges that they face."
  },
  {
    "start": 1870.66,
    "end": 1878.3,
    "text": "And this work, it was really exciting because It showed us the flow patterns inside these networks were high dimensional."
  },
  {
    "start": 1878.88,
    "end": 1880.52,
    "text": "They contained a lot of information."
  },
  {
    "start": 1881.0,
    "end": 1888.46,
    "text": "The fungi were modulating velocity and direction even viscosity Of their internal flows throughout network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1889.2,
    "end": 1901.42,
    "text": "Now, this is sort of the first hint of trying to decode something in an organism that allows us really understand how they're making decisions and how their interacting with world."
  },
  {
    "start": 1901.78,
    "end": 1903.6,
    "text": "How there processing information."
  },
  {
    "start": 1904.1,
    "end": 1919.02,
    "text": "so it feels like a really exciting time right now to be able to peek into inner lives of fungi And together with some other techniques that we're developing, We can actually track individual decision points."
  },
  {
    "start": 1919.28,
    "end": 1923.84,
    "text": "Would you were able to measure the velocity of these flows?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1924.18,
    "end": 1926.02,
    "text": "Yeah and they are very fast!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1926.08,
    "end": 1929.38,
    "text": "I think people don't really understand... how they work."
  },
  {
    "start": 1929.48,
    "end": 1935.26,
    "text": "This is the first time we saw them, the biophysicists at The Institute were flabbergast!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1935.46,
    "end": 1939.8,
    "text": "They just could not believe these kinds of dynamics where functioning inside the network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1939.9,
    "end": 1954.26,
    "text": "so you have to picture almost like a tube an open tube and imagine a river flowing through it but instead of the river moving in one direction which is usually how rivers flow Imagine having two currents."
  },
  {
    "start": 1957.66,
    "end": 1958.74,
    "text": "Now, this is wild."
  },
  {
    "start": 1958.78,
    "end": 1965.3,
    "text": "This isn't usually how cells operate but it's really important for these fungi because imagine what has to happen?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1965.7,
    "end": 1971.6,
    "text": "The plants are taking carbon from the root system and it has get all of a way down into tip of the fungal network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1972.7,
    "end": 1978.22,
    "text": "simultaneously Of course, the fungi collecting resources moving in opposite direction."
  },
  {
    "start": 1978.78,
    "end": 1983.18,
    "text": "so you can actually start seeing dynamics inside the network."
  },
  {
    "start": 1983.46,
    "end": 1994.28,
    "text": "And it's fascinating, I mean once you see and how exquisitely sensitive these networks are to small changes in their environment... You're basically hooked for life!"
  },
  {
    "start": 1995.26,
    "end": 1997.16,
    "text": "I can't imagine… How quick they are?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1997.2,
    "end": 1999.1,
    "text": "Are there like five kilometers per hour?"
  },
  {
    "start": 1999.28,
    "end": 2001.82,
    "text": "or do you know?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2002.2,
    "end": 2004.16,
    "text": "Or have been able to witness"
  },
  {
    "start": 2004.52,
    "end": 2004.74,
    "text": "that?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2004.88,
    "end": 2006.84,
    "text": "Yeah yeah.. The speeds are quite slow."
  },
  {
    "start": 2007.44,
    "end": 2012.08,
    "text": "We did one calculation, because it's in a small tube and its microscopic organism."
  },
  {
    "start": 2013.18,
    "end": 2023.16,
    "text": "It is to our perspective quite slow movement but we did the calculation that if you were inside of network would feel like moving about forty kilometers an hour."
  },
  {
    "start": 2023.52,
    "end": 2023.76,
    "text": "Wow!"
  },
  {
    "start": 2023.86,
    "end": 2028.26,
    "text": "So If your are a small particle inside the network feels like you're moving pretty fast."
  },
  {
    "start": 2029.22,
    "end": 2034.1,
    "text": "so actually fascinating how they modulate these flows."
  },
  {
    "start": 2035.6,
    "end": 2044.54,
    "text": "It's really changed our perspective and I think by being able to image them, it also shows the world just how alive the underground is."
  },
  {
    "start": 2044.94,
    "end": 2055.259,
    "text": "And we're starting to really start thinking about these networks as an underground circulatory system because they are responsible for so much carbon movement."
  },
  {
    "start": 2057.5,
    "end": 2059.139,
    "text": "billion tons, it's a big number."
  },
  {
    "start": 2059.3,
    "end": 2073.98,
    "text": "Thirteen billion tons of carbon are processed by plants above ground and then fed to mycorrhizal networks every year so that's equivalent to roughly a third of emissions from fossil fuels or being processed by plans in Fed."
  },
  {
    "start": 2074.1,
    "end": 2076.42,
    "text": "two these networks across the earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 2076.52,
    "end": 2084.6,
    "text": "And so It's quite interesting To understand once that carbon gets into the network How do the fungi move at end?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2086.5,
    "end": 2094.22,
    "text": "We're developing some new techniques right now in the lab where we actually can tag the carbon with a fluorescent label."
  },
  {
    "start": 2094.9,
    "end": 2103.04,
    "text": "And so, we can visually track both sort of global resource distribution patterns but also individual decision points were small."
  },
  {
    "start": 2103.68,
    "end": 2112.64,
    "text": "blob-of-carbon will come to an adjunction on road and watch which direction it goes or if it splits perfectly in half."
  },
  {
    "start": 2113.32,
    "end": 2113.94,
    "text": "Fantastic."
  },
  {
    "start": 2114.04,
    "end": 2126.48,
    "text": "You know, I was picturing a metropolis at night when you're watching the different cars going in different directions and then you mentioned the neofluorescent light And then i thought that's Miami."
  },
  {
    "start": 2127.28,
    "end": 2127.6,
    "text": "Yes."
  },
  {
    "start": 2128.22,
    "end": 2137.5,
    "text": "Yeah, sometimes we show images of traffic jams in LA at Thanksgiving with cars moving in both directions you know and these long lines."
  },
  {
    "start": 2137.94,
    "end": 2138.96,
    "text": "but what's different about this?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2139.04,
    "end": 2139.7,
    "text": "road systems?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2139.78,
    "end": 2141.74,
    "text": "is that there a barrier You know?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2142.2,
    "end": 2149.26,
    "text": "In our road system to make sure the car are going either north or south But it's an open pipe tube."
  },
  {
    "start": 2149.42,
    "end": 2153.38,
    "text": "so really still trying understand how they control them"
  },
  {
    "start": 2153.76,
    "end": 2154.38,
    "text": "Amazing."
  },
  {
    "start": 2154.76,
    "end": 2166.92,
    "text": "Well, the thing that I found fascinating about your approach is you don't use the analogy of exchanges in Fungal Network simply to draw parallels between their world and ours."
  },
  {
    "start": 2168.32,
    "end": 2184.72,
    "text": "You go much deeper using this analogy as a kind-of cognitive brilliant umbed translation tool which helps us understand behaviors happening underground in a way humans can actually relate to."
  },
  {
    "start": 2185.62,
    "end": 2186.24,
    "text": "Is that right?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2186.34,
    "end": 2190.06,
    "text": "Could we see the market theory framework as a cognitive"
  },
  {
    "start": 2190.24,
    "end": 2190.5,
    "text": "tool?\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 2191.2,
    "end": 2196.38,
    "text": "Yeah, so I think where it's important to be very careful about language here."
  },
  {
    "start": 2197.04,
    "end": 2216.3,
    "text": "And this idea of market economies as an analogy to describe trade between plant roots and mycorrhizal fungi—and But it can also be an analytical tool."
  },
  {
    "start": 2216.92,
    "end": 2225.7,
    "text": "So what economics does is, gives us a real mathematical framework to analyze trade strategies in very predictive quantitative manner."
  },
  {
    "start": 2226.0,
    "end": 2234.52,
    "text": "and this I give an example of grooming markets between non-human primates."
  },
  {
    "start": 2235.02,
    "end": 2252.44,
    "text": "For example, this is work of Ronald Noe here who's in the Netherlands who started working with these primate groups and seeing that he could make predictions like a certain amount of food was given for a certain number of grooming or service but as that food availability goes up price goes down."
  },
  {
    "start": 2253.04,
    "end": 2265.86,
    "text": "so it wasn't analytical framework called biological market theory just allowed us to start trying to make predictions about what we thought an organism would do under a certain context, under certain amount of resources."
  },
  {
    "start": 2266.58,
    "end": 2275.76,
    "text": "And so I think we can play with these same principles with other organisms in nature even those ones that don't have a central nervous system."
  },
  {
    "start": 2276.24,
    "end": 2280.64,
    "text": "there's no real need for a Central Nervous System like a brain to be able to calculate."
  },
  {
    "start": 2281.04,
    "end": 2282.98,
    "text": "it's instead the strategies."
  },
  {
    "start": 2283.02,
    "end": 2294.62,
    "text": "they're going to be under strong selection from evolution and If you gave away, let's say all of your carbon to any old fungal strain and got nothing in return it wouldn't last very long."
  },
  {
    "start": 2295.44,
    "end": 2302.7,
    "text": "And so over time, these strategies have evolved that really allow partners to be able to discriminate."
  },
  {
    "start": 2302.86,
    "end": 2305.54,
    "text": "I would say about different trading partners."
  },
  {
    "start": 2306.12,
    "end": 2316.96,
    "text": "That's what we're trying to understand is can plants and fungi interact in a way where they are able tell the good partner from bad partner?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2317.58,
    "end": 2331.66,
    "text": "We could think of this as almost a science of discrimination—what do is to set up experiments to actually test if plants could discriminate from less effective and more effective fungal strains."
  },
  {
    "start": 2332.24,
    "end": 2342.22,
    "text": "And of course, this is key data because it would suggest that there's some mechanism that allows partners to sense when they're getting a good deal or not."
  },
  {
    "start": 2342.92,
    "end": 2344.36,
    "text": "And what does it take to discriminate?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2344.4,
    "end": 2348.86,
    "text": "What are the exact mechanisms, and that's really a fundamental requirement."
  },
  {
    "start": 2348.92,
    "end": 2352.94,
    "text": "To be a successful organism is the ability to sense the amount of"
  },
  {
    "start": 2353.06,
    "end": 2353.8,
    "text": "resources.\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 2354.64,
    "end": 2370.64,
    "text": "So this where we started trying to set up experiments about discrimination... ...and trying to understand how these organisms interact in way that allows them to maximize the number of resources they're able get themselves."
  },
  {
    "start": 2371.2,
    "end": 2372.48,
    "text": "I think this is brilliant."
  },
  {
    "start": 2372.66,
    "end": 2378.86,
    "text": "This is hardcore science and i see why you won the MacArthur Genius Award."
  },
  {
    "start": 2379.2,
    "end": 2380.32,
    "text": "Yes, that's just happened."
  },
  {
    "start": 2380.38,
    "end": 2388.62,
    "text": "It was quite a surprise and it is really exciting because I think this was the first time that The MacArthur Foundation recognized someone studying fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 2389.34,
    "end": 2395.28,
    "text": "so sometimes it does feel like these awards in particular are much more for them than us."
  },
  {
    "start": 2395.42,
    "end": 2410.2,
    "text": "but if we have some patience to study those trade dynamics with tools emerging right now then we can uncover sophisticated strategies I would say that have evolved over time."
  },
  {
    "start": 2410.54,
    "end": 2416.7,
    "text": "Absolutely, let's go a bit deeper into these exchanges happening underneath our feet."
  },
  {
    "start": 2417.1,
    "end": 2427.4,
    "text": "Well market theory as you've been explaining only works when the trader has multiple trade partners and fungal networks As we just learned are no exception."
  },
  {
    "start": 2427.84,
    "end": 2439.06,
    "text": "so since energy drives everything in both ecosystems and economies There's, I think an incredible complexity as I've understanding happening in these exchanges processes."
  },
  {
    "start": 2439.78,
    "end": 2453.72,
    "text": "And if we think of carbon as the currency—their currency–in this underground market... In what ways can a change-in-carbon availability shift the balance of power between plants and fungi?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2454.42,
    "end": 2455.02,
    "text": "Are those shifts"
  },
  {
    "start": 2455.36,
    "end": 2455.98,
    "text": "dramatic?\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 2456.4,
    "end": 2457.94,
    "text": "How are the shifts dramatic?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2458.12,
    "end": 2464.64,
    "text": "I mean, they are to us that you know when we set up these experiments in the lab but i think it's a good question."
  },
  {
    "start": 2464.78,
    "end": 2474.22,
    "text": "I mean changing resource availability constantly shifts balance of power as does changing the number of partners in a relationship right."
  },
  {
    "start": 2474.28,
    "end": 2482.62,
    "text": "if you're just in a monopoly then not really changes the strategies that you can evolve rather than if your interacting with numerous partner simultaneously."
  },
  {
    "start": 2483.5,
    "end": 2490.0,
    "text": "so we can look at theory and try to understand when trade is likely to be favored."
  },
  {
    "start": 2490.56,
    "end": 2505.8,
    "text": "And for example, we know that trade is favored when individuals interact with multiple partners of both species—and also when there's a greater let's say relative difference between species in their ability to acquire resources!"
  },
  {
    "start": 2506.22,
    "end": 2521.02,
    "text": "So if there's very small differences between species expect trade to emerge, but if there is a bigger ability that's when we start seeing these differences and trade really being driven."
  },
  {
    "start": 2521.24,
    "end": 2524.64,
    "text": "And so when you say how does changing the amount of carbon?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2525.08,
    "end": 2529.58,
    "text": "Yes something like that can really change and shift the power dynamics."
  },
  {
    "start": 2530.16,
    "end": 2535.44,
    "text": "Are they parts off the network that work like hubs or exchange houses for trading?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2536.0,
    "end": 2542.34,
    "text": "in other words this trading happen at specific points are using more a diffuse process."
  },
  {
    "start": 2543.54,
    "end": 2553.02,
    "text": "No, so trade in these networks between plants and mycorrhizal fungi happen at very specialized structures called arbuscules."
  },
  {
    "start": 2553.88,
    "end": 2557.88,
    "text": "Arbuscules are actually called arbuscular mycorhizal funghi."
  },
  {
    "start": 2558.54,
    "end": 2563.68,
    "text": "Arbuscules are beautiful structures that are formed and found inside plant roots."
  },
  {
    "start": 2563.76,
    "end": 2579.14,
    "text": "So you can imagine a mycorhisal network is actually penetrating into our root cell And then it forms this very intricate and delicate structure called an arboscule that looks like a mini tree, actually inside the network."
  },
  {
    "start": 2579.78,
    "end": 2581.92,
    "text": "Why is it so convoluted?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2582.48,
    "end": 2587.2,
    "text": "Like a tree with branches means really has high surface to volume ratio."
  },
  {
    "start": 2587.8,
    "end": 2594.54,
    "text": "So there's many places for trade to happen on particular structures And that's where the tray takes place."
  },
  {
    "start": 2594.58,
    "end": 2603.04,
    "text": "That is where the carbon is loaded into the fungal network, and this is where phosphorus is exchanged from the fungalside."
  },
  {
    "start": 2603.78,
    "end": 2608.28,
    "text": "Now, there's a lot of work going on trying to understand the dynamics."
  },
  {
    "start": 2608.66,
    "end": 2615.38,
    "text": "These are buskills because they're such powerhouses where interaction takes place and still so much to learn."
  },
  {
    "start": 2615.92,
    "end": 2626.96,
    "text": "but one interesting thing that scientists have discovered in recent years is just how ephemeral they can form then collapse typically within about seven days."
  },
  {
    "start": 2627.52,
    "end": 2637.8,
    "text": "And that also leads to very interesting trade dynamics, because it means the one spot where bartering is happening can only happen for a short time and then disappears."
  },
  {
    "start": 2639.0,
    "end": 2646.64,
    "text": "The fungus seems to colonize down the root system so once its already traded with one root cell, it doesn't tend to re-infect."
  },
  {
    "start": 2647.08,
    "end": 2653.52,
    "text": "So it makes this wave of colonization as it moves down the growing root system where the trade is taking"
  },
  {
    "start": 2653.6,
    "end": 2653.96,
    "text": "place.\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 2654.64,
    "end": 2656.8,
    "text": "This really sounds like magic!"
  },
  {
    "start": 2657.64,
    "end": 2661.28,
    "text": "It IS when you're in a lab and actually looks like magic too."
  },
  {
    "start": 2661.32,
    "end": 2673.38,
    "text": "But Professor Kirsch could share perhaps an experiment that you would run through which we can picture how you track these processes."
  },
  {
    "start": 2673.46,
    "end": 2684.42,
    "text": "You were naming already with this light and so, but maybe some specifics on how may be shift the balances of power in these exchanges?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2685.34,
    "end": 2691.58,
    "text": "Of course, these experiments are always hard to describe because there's so many things happening simultaneously."
  },
  {
    "start": 2692.82,
    "end": 2697.04,
    "text": "But first you have to picture a Petri plate and... Because this is essential!"
  },
  {
    "start": 2697.08,
    "end": 2703.32,
    "text": "This all of our work takes place in very sterile lab conditions."
  },
  {
    "start": 2703.74,
    "end": 2709.22,
    "text": "And that's another whole conversation about what we're finding the lab whether it can be translated out into nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 2710.04,
    "end": 2715.22,
    "text": "but if imagine a plate, we've got a root system on one side of that plate."
  },
  {
    "start": 2715.52,
    "end": 2720.28,
    "text": "so it looks kind of like sort-of a messy network of plant roots."
  },
  {
    "start": 2721.4,
    "end": 2731.56,
    "text": "We colonize that root system with the fungi and then the fungi cross over this barrier into what we call the fungal arena—and that's where all the magic takes place!"
  },
  {
    "start": 2732.86,
    "end": 2737.86,
    "text": "And this is an area where it's just the fungi growing, and then we can manipulate the fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 2738.36,
    "end": 2743.86,
    "text": "however we want adding more resources or adding things that it doesn't like."
  },
  {
    "start": 2743.92,
    "end": 2746.34,
    "text": "Things that it likes mazes all kinds of things."
  },
  {
    "start": 2747.76,
    "end": 2752.32,
    "text": "And one of the experiments that we did, this is something that was published in I think two thousand nineteen."
  },
  {
    "start": 2752.96,
    "end": 2758.9,
    "text": "Was really wanted to understand how fungi themselves deal with being exposed."
  },
  {
    "start": 2759.08,
    "end": 2767.22,
    "text": "inequality meaning if they're exposed too very differences high differences and resource availability across a single network?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2767.64,
    "end": 2768.58,
    "text": "How do you deal with that?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2768.78,
    "end": 2770.72,
    "text": "terms on how they trade what the plant route?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2771.58,
    "end": 2775.54,
    "text": "In this case, we had an experiment in a triple plate compartment."
  },
  {
    "start": 2775.76,
    "end": 2777.72,
    "text": "That means it was broken up into three parts."
  },
  {
    "start": 2778.32,
    "end": 2782.02,
    "text": "One part is the root system and other two were the fungal arenas."
  },
  {
    "start": 2783.86,
    "end": 2787.18,
    "text": "We developed these techniques using quantum dots."
  },
  {
    "start": 2787.68,
    "end": 2801.64,
    "text": "Quantum dots are nanoparticles that fluoresce in very bright pure colors when exposed to UV light source And attach those quantum dots with appetite phosphorus."
  },
  {
    "start": 2802.68,
    "end": 2802.84,
    "text": "And"
  },
  {
    "start": 2803.22,
    "end": 2812.14,
    "text": "so you can just imagine we created phosphorous that was either blue or red, and then put the phosphorous into compartments at different concentrations."
  },
  {
    "start": 2812.6,
    "end": 2820.98,
    "text": "So the most interesting treatment of course is when one side of network was exposed to lots of resources... ...and other was exposed in just the tiniest amount."
  },
  {
    "start": 2821.42,
    "end": 2826.64,
    "text": "In this case it's a difference of ninety percent of the resource went in one compartment and ten percent on another."
  },
  {
    "start": 2827.2,
    "end": 2830.4,
    "text": "Now, because these resources were different colors we could see one."
  },
  {
    "start": 2830.68,
    "end": 2835.96,
    "text": "We can see what the fungi then did with movement of this phosphorus resource."
  },
  {
    "start": 2837.1,
    "end": 2852.8,
    "text": "What we found which was stunning to even us is that they responded in a quality by actually moving from rich compartment and poor compartment where they traded with plant root."
  },
  {
    "start": 2853.5,
    "end": 2854.94,
    "text": "Okay, so why would they do that?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2855.08,
    "end": 2855.3,
    "text": "Right."
  },
  {
    "start": 2855.36,
    "end": 2863.88,
    "text": "They actively move the resources from the rich patches to the poor patches and we think that they did this to really capitalize on demand differences."
  },
  {
    "start": 2864.56,
    "end": 2871.62,
    "text": "So The root system That was growing On the poor side of the network Was willing To pay more phosphorus."
  },
  {
    "start": 2872.1,
    "end": 2875.16,
    "text": "So the demand on that Side Of the Network was higher."
  },
  {
    "start": 2876.32,
    "end": 2885.42,
    "text": "What it looks like is that the fungi are actually moving the Phosphorus to a place where they're able more unit, more carbon per unit phosphorus."
  },
  {
    "start": 2886.18,
    "end": 2893.76,
    "text": "So the fungus gains more by moving the phosphorous within the networks to areas of higher demand really places where the host was willing to pay more."
  },
  {
    "start": 2894.86,
    "end": 2899.48,
    "text": "Incredible and how long does an experiment like this typically take?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2899.52,
    "end": 2902.72,
    "text": "And what kind of budget does it usually require?"
  },
  {
    "start": 2903.52,
    "end": 2907.34,
    "text": "Yeah, these are achingly precise experiments."
  },
  {
    "start": 2907.38,
    "end": 2910.88,
    "text": "So I think that the setup of the experiment is what takes so long."
  },
  {
    "start": 2910.96,
    "end": 2934.62,
    "text": "there's so many pilot projects to make sure that the right amount of nutrients and all of the controls they're taken care of but no toxicity involved with this new difference let say in size at the quantum dots if one is red or blue If also lots and lots of separate control experiments go on testing what we think were testing."
  },
  {
    "start": 2935.5,
    "end": 2946.36,
    "text": "So an experiment like that to actually pull it off, I think it was about two years from start to finish building the robot for example as a multi-year project."
  },
  {
    "start": 2946.96,
    "end": 2950.02,
    "text": "three or four years um to develop that one."
  },
  {
    "start": 2950.68,
    "end": 2952.26,
    "text": "but the experiments themselves."
  },
  {
    "start": 2952.38,
    "end": 2956.08,
    "text": "where we're just growing the fungi and everything is in place then there are enough replicates."
  },
  {
    "start": 2957.08,
    "end": 2961.6,
    "text": "those usually last between Two and three weeks."
  },
  {
    "start": 2961.68,
    "end": 2969.9,
    "text": "Sometimes we grow the fungi up to about six weeks, but a lot of the dynamics happen within the first couple weeks after they cross into the fungal arena."
  },
  {
    "start": 2970.84,
    "end": 2976.22,
    "text": "But the fungi are very slow growing compared to some molds that you would imagine, let's say in your kitchen."
  },
  {
    "start": 2976.8,
    "end": 2988.56,
    "text": "These are our very slow-growing networks and so first you have to make sure that their root is fully colonized—that they're colonized to the same amount —that the fungi aren't evenly crossing into the fungal compartment."
  },
  {
    "start": 2988.66,
    "end": 2994.6,
    "text": "So start with about a hundred replicates And by the time everything has to be accounted for."
  },
  {
    "start": 2995.02,
    "end": 3000.18,
    "text": "then get about fifteen replicats tracking these dynamics in."
  },
  {
    "start": 3001.18,
    "end": 3010.4,
    "text": "Well, speaking of technology let's hear from the extraordinary British choreographer Alexander Whitley founder of The Company that bears his name."
  },
  {
    "start": 3011.18,
    "end": 3019.2,
    "text": "In his pioneer work he explores the tension and evolving relationship between human bodies And technological systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 3019.88,
    "end": 3024.86,
    "text": "here He shares how technology can disrupt the natural flow Of movement in dance."
  },
  {
    "start": 3025.1,
    "end": 3031.94,
    "text": "Let's listen Technology does generally break that flow."
  },
  {
    "start": 3032.32,
    "end": 3048.36,
    "text": "It introduces elements that work at different paces, they have different rhythms and there's a lot of work that goes into developing the technology to the point where it is functional enough to get somewhere close to a low state in creativity."
  },
  {
    "start": 3056.64,
    "end": 3072.8,
    "text": "You can be very frustrating because I as a dancer and choreographer you know the dancers i've worked with are all too aware and knowledgeable about what Flow state can be when it works, and just the speed at which ideas emerge should be developed through interpersonal communication."
  },
  {
    "start": 3074.24,
    "end": 3077.4,
    "text": "Bringing technology into a mix slows that down and could be"
  },
  {
    "start": 3077.5,
    "end": 3078.06,
    "text": "frustrating.\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 3081.26,
    "end": 3088.54,
    "text": "Hearing Alexander Whitley describe how technological interventions alter natural flow shifting patterns and dynamics."
  },
  {
    "start": 3111.14,
    "end": 3111.2,
    "text": "So"
  },
  {
    "start": 3111.26,
    "end": 3112.92,
    "text": "that's a big question we have."
  },
  {
    "start": 3113.42,
    "end": 3126.7,
    "text": "In terms of technology in the lab and getting into flow state, I think one of the things that our technologies have allowed us to do is actually observe fungi in their flow state, literally."
  },
  {
    "start": 3127.28,
    "end": 3136.76,
    "text": "And that's because of technology we wouldn't be able to do that with are very sort-of course and blunt tools that we need to use in real ecosystems."
  },
  {
    "start": 3137.4,
    "end": 3144.88,
    "text": "here In The Lab We can build these technologies and machines That allow Us To observe Fungi almost untouched."
  },
  {
    "start": 3145.44,
    "end": 3150.0,
    "text": "And that's really exciting for us, because again if we're asking the question what is it like to be you?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3150.74,
    "end": 3157.9,
    "text": "We want to be able to observe without disturbing and really the technologies in the lab—that's what their aim is to do!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3158.82,
    "end": 3161.7,
    "text": "You can imagine —we have these big dark rooms."
  },
  {
    "start": 3161.78,
    "end": 3170.14,
    "text": "I mean everything has to be in the dark when you are taking some of this and growing these networks…and try make as realistic soil systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 3171.36,
    "end": 3181.36,
    "text": "Of course, that's never possible but the technologies in our sense allow us to really capture what would almost be impossible in natural ecosystems."
  },
  {
    "start": 3181.86,
    "end": 3200.68,
    "text": "And if you wanted to observe those same processes at a scale of real habitat say an entire forest do you think it is realistically achievable with todays technology and resources or still beyond reach because cost technical limitations?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3201.64,
    "end": 3206.64,
    "text": "Yes, this is a great question and one that we think about all the time in our lab."
  },
  {
    "start": 3207.04,
    "end": 3218.46,
    "text": "We again very highly controlled conditions in the lab make it possible to track half-a-million decision points on a fungal network in space and time."
  },
  {
    "start": 3218.96,
    "end": 3223.6,
    "text": "as soon you go out into nature everything changes All bets are off."
  },
  {
    "start": 3224.28,
    "end": 3227.0,
    "text": "You can think of ecosystems really outside the lab."
  },
  {
    "start": 3227.08,
    "end": 3229.38,
    "text": "there's just like an opera of interactions."
  },
  {
    "start": 3231.24,
    "end": 3237.32,
    "text": "Translating what we find into field conditions, I think is really the next big frontier."
  },
  {
    "start": 3238.1,
    "end": 3245.08,
    "text": "It's really hard to do and in some cases it's about resources—and a will!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3245.54,
    "end": 3255.2,
    "text": "Even if just a fraction of the resources that would go let us say into studying space... ...would go into studying underground then i think we could develop tools…."
  },
  {
    "start": 3255.68,
    "end": 3259.84,
    "text": "…to be able track resources in natural environments."
  },
  {
    "start": 3260.48,
    "end": 3262.14,
    "text": "But right now, it's totally out of reach."
  },
  {
    "start": 3262.84,
    "end": 3276.5,
    "text": "So we spend a lot of time trying to advocate for more funding and more research... ...to go into studying these in situ situations… …in real soil ecosystems because that is where all bets are off!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3276.82,
    "end": 3278.18,
    "text": "We're really interested as well."
  },
  {
    "start": 3278.44,
    "end": 3278.72,
    "text": "how"
  },
  {
    "start": 3279.22,
    "end": 3280.8,
    "text": "exactly does this work?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3281.54,
    "end": 3282.96,
    "text": "You know what I think its important."
  },
  {
    "start": 3283.18,
    "end": 3301.6,
    "text": "you mention about exploring the outer space And that reminded me of Merlin Sheldrick's Entangled Life, his book which I am about to finish where he mentions if you teased apart the mycelium in just a teaspoon of soil it could stretch four kilometers."
  },
  {
    "start": 3302.24,
    "end": 3316.46,
    "text": "Globally the total length of the micro-rysal fungal mycelia in top ten sensors is more than... and i put in my notes.. ...four hundred fifty quadrillion kilometers which is over half of the width of the galaxy."
  },
  {
    "start": 3317.34,
    "end": 3322.84,
    "text": "So in a way, it's also like exploring outer space but just beneath our feet."
  },
  {
    "start": 3324.44,
    "end": 3325.08,
    "text": "Yeah, exactly."
  },
  {
    "start": 3325.74,
    "end": 3341.56,
    "text": "So we're working right now on trying to update those numbers based on what we are seeing with our robotic imaging and more data coming in of people going out sampling soils across the Earth and understanding the density of these networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 3342.84,
    "end": 3349.1,
    "text": "The number which we hope to publish sometime soon is really enormous And it's fascinating."
  },
  {
    "start": 3350.7,
    "end": 3355.78,
    "text": "What it does is, its not so much about the number itself but it's trying to give shape."
  },
  {
    "start": 3355.88,
    "end": 3367.58,
    "text": "Trying a sense of this underground circulatory system and all these fungal communities that are down there who are responsible for our carbon cycle or nutrient cycle or water cycle."
  },
  {
    "start": 3368.1,
    "end": 3372.0,
    "text": "Trying understand infrastructure because thats been hidden again."
  },
  {
    "start": 3372.1,
    "end": 3375.66,
    "text": "I think those tools can help us understand whats happening now"
  },
  {
    "start": 3376.16,
    "end": 3376.7,
    "text": "Absolutely."
  },
  {
    "start": 3377.22,
    "end": 3390.54,
    "text": "And going back to the arboscular mycorrhizal fungi, these tree-like structures that form inside the plant root cells and disappear... ...and what trading happens and decision making happens."
  },
  {
    "start": 3391.22,
    "end": 3397.34,
    "text": "Let's hear ecologist Carl Zafina again this time on his idea of intelligence in a living world…."
  },
  {
    "start": 3397.82,
    "end": 3402.92,
    "text": "…and he is an example how problem solving can happen even without brain or nervous system."
  },
  {
    "start": 3403.54,
    "end": 3413.22,
    "text": "We'll follow that with the Catherine Hale's perspective on how cognition is built and the distinction she makes between cognitive systems, which she calls actors."
  },
  {
    "start": 3413.74,
    "end": 3416.32,
    "text": "And physical processes, Which She Calls Agents."
  },
  {
    "start": 3416.56,
    "end": 3417.1,
    "text": "Let's listen."
  },
  {
    "start": 3418.78,
    "end": 3427.34,
    "text": "My idea of intelligence Is The ability to Find a new solution To A New Problem."
  },
  {
    "start": 3427.78,
    "end": 3429.62,
    "text": "So That has to do With Creativity."
  },
  {
    "start": 3430.06,
    "end": 3449.56,
    "text": "You know you've never seen this problem before But You Can Think Of Something To Do To Solve The Problem Whether an animal can figure out a way of solving a new situation or confronting a new problem and how good they are at that, And How many things They can solve."
  },
  {
    "start": 3449.76,
    "end": 3457.92,
    "text": "I think That shows A range Of intelligence Experiments with slime molds."
  },
  {
    "start": 3458.46,
    "end": 3462.6,
    "text": "They Are very mind-blowing Because It is single cell."
  },
  {
    "start": 3462.64,
    "end": 3465.36,
    "text": "They're pretty big Hundreds of nuclei."
  },
  {
    "start": 3465.58,
    "end": 3466.12,
    "text": "Who ever heard?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3466.88,
    "end": 3470.94,
    "text": "And yeah, they figure stuff out and they can remember it."
  },
  {
    "start": 3471.36,
    "end": 3476.38,
    "text": "So that challenge is almost everything we think about intelligence."
  },
  {
    "start": 3476.84,
    "end": 3480.32,
    "text": "We usually thing you cant be intelligent without a nervous system."
  },
  {
    "start": 3480.52,
    "end": 3481.74,
    "text": "Well They only have one cell."
  },
  {
    "start": 3482.36,
    "end": 3489.76,
    "text": "It's not a neuron But there are things going on in the cells That are very like what happens with a nervous systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 3490.1,
    "end": 3491.08,
    "text": "but how does this happen?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3491.6,
    "end": 3493.36,
    "text": "There s alot of mysteries with slime molds."
  },
  {
    "start": 3494.04,
    "end": 3505.02,
    "text": "I think they give us a lot humility When we think, when you understand something about brains or minds and then were confronted with a single cell that can solve problem in the most efficient way possible."
  },
  {
    "start": 3505.4,
    "end": 3505.56,
    "text": "You know?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3505.62,
    "end": 3506.44,
    "text": "That's really amazing."
  },
  {
    "start": 3509.9,
    "end": 3519.02,
    "text": "All cognition is built on physical and chemical processes... ...that's foundation from which all higher capabilities emerge."
  },
  {
    "start": 3519.62,
    "end": 3529.0,
    "text": "but I distinguish between Cognitive systems, which have the ability to perform interpretations and make selections or choices."
  },
  {
    "start": 3529.76,
    "end": 3532.94,
    "text": "And purely physical chemical processes."
  },
  {
    "start": 3533.64,
    "end": 3540.56,
    "text": "so I call cognitive agents actors... ...and physical-chemical process agents."
  },
  {
    "start": 3540.86,
    "end": 3543.78,
    "text": "So i'm distinguishing between Actors & Agents."
  },
  {
    "start": 3544.4,
    "end": 3549.12,
    "text": "So an example of a Process that has agency would be a tornado."
  },
  {
    "start": 3549.44,
    "end": 3554.76,
    "text": "but A Tornado is incapable Performing interpretations are making selections."
  },
  {
    "start": 3554.86,
    "end": 3568.9,
    "text": "It doesn't choose where it goes, its just the resultant of all the physical forces acting upon it whereas all living organisms have the capability to make selections and perform interpretations."
  },
  {
    "start": 3569.44,
    "end": 3577.34,
    "text": "so all living organism is actors, physical chemical or material processes in themselves our agents."
  },
  {
    "start": 3581.66,
    "end": 3584.9,
    "text": "So it seems that cognition can exist without a brain."
  },
  {
    "start": 3585.62,
    "end": 3607.9,
    "text": "And from what Professor Hales explained, only living things have these age and level processes built into them... ...and on THAT note the one-in-only gathering chaos has actually left a question for you professor Kiers!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3608.16,
    "end": 3616.92,
    "text": "And I should just note that I define cognition as a process of interpreting information in contexts connected with meaning."
  },
  {
    "start": 3617.78,
    "end": 3626.0,
    "text": "So perhaps through calcium ion channels, but i leave this for you to consider thank-you."
  },
  {
    "start": 3626.92,
    "end": 3627.98,
    "text": "Well, fungi are actors."
  },
  {
    "start": 3628.14,
    "end": 3630.94,
    "text": "They're living beings and they have evolved strategies."
  },
  {
    "start": 3631.42,
    "end": 3638.8,
    "text": "but those strategies are based on agent processes like chemical and physical changes in the environment."
  },
  {
    "start": 3640.08,
    "end": 3650.2,
    "text": "I think we tend to be limited In our definition of intelligence And so many ways because We tend to recognize intelligence only for what we see ourselves."
  },
  {
    "start": 3650.38,
    "end": 3653.86,
    "text": "So it's quite hard For us To know What is a good decision?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3654.92,
    "end": 3655.9,
    "text": "a micro-isle fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 3657.22,
    "end": 3670.5,
    "text": "What we do know and this is really important, these are strategies that have been shaped by natural selection for hundreds of millions of years in some of the most complex habitats on earth right?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3670.58,
    "end": 3675.0,
    "text": "I mean scientists say soils are THE most complex habitat on all over Earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 3675.9,
    "end": 3686.98,
    "text": "so when you think about fungi they live their lives just bathed in rich fields of sensory information."
  },
  {
    "start": 3687.94,
    "end": 3709.54,
    "text": "And I think it's our job to try to understand how they process that information across their bodies, how they use that information as being able to process information."
  },
  {
    "start": 3712.54,
    "end": 3723.7,
    "text": "When they perform strategies and when we're able to capture that data, it's fascinating because what their doing is quite complex if you really take a step back!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3723.98,
    "end": 3740.36,
    "text": "They are collecting and trading nutrients which means they have to be integrating very complex data streams across billions of growing tips could be connected between several different plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 3741.1,
    "end": 3755.06,
    "text": "So we have to realize that they're not just open conduits where these nutrients flow, but really that their controlling carbon and nutrient flow with I guess i would say surprising precision?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3755.62,
    "end": 3761.26,
    "text": "And that's really allowing them to resolve some of the most complicated supply chain trade-offs?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3762.16,
    "end": 3762.68,
    "text": "Absolutely!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3763.18,
    "end": 3774.4,
    "text": "When you talk about strategies I think about intention behind these strategies because at the end there's this driving force to reproduce and survive, right?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3774.8,
    "end": 3775.24,
    "text": "Of course."
  },
  {
    "start": 3775.52,
    "end": 3780.92,
    "text": "That built into our own DNA is the ability to reproduce or survive."
  },
  {
    "start": 3780.96,
    "end": 3790.86,
    "text": "that helps us define what a living organism is And that's what's exciting about the work we're doing right now is answering that exact question."
  },
  {
    "start": 3791.16,
    "end": 3799.42,
    "text": "Again, I like to use information processing and trying really dig in how it works."
  },
  {
    "start": 3800.08,
    "end": 3809.9,
    "text": "One of our experiments all of the different mechanisms by which these fungi may be processing information."
  },
  {
    "start": 3810.46,
    "end": 3838.5,
    "text": "And one of those is to look at actual electrical activity in these networks, living organisms of course rely on all kinds of electrical activity voltage changes in ion channels to be able to sense their environment and we're working with a really talented postdoc right now that's actually able to build these micropipettes, half a micron across using almost artistry."
  },
  {
    "start": 3838.66,
    "end": 3851.5,
    "text": "To be able to blow glass to such degree pull this glass tip and it is incredibly tiny And then puncture an individual hyphae in complex networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 3852.0,
    "end": 3864.54,
    "text": "So its like the skill of surgeon using really small micro manipulator the hyphae with a single pipette tip, and this allows us to study voltage changes like actually understand electrical activity."
  },
  {
    "start": 3865.3,
    "end": 3880.78,
    "text": "So this is whole new field that we're getting into right now actually introduced a stimuli to the network and then see how that information may be moving across the network by measuring voltage changes."
  },
  {
    "start": 3882.06,
    "end": 3891.56,
    "text": "So stay tuned because there's a lot of work, it'll probably take several years to do this correctly but we really want you to understand what are underlying mechanisms?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3892.02,
    "end": 3900.88,
    "text": "One big question is whether decisions in fungal networks dominated by what we call local rules or global rule."
  },
  {
    "start": 3901.02,
    "end": 3908.52,
    "text": "So is there just something happening very locally that allows, you know at tens of thousands of tips to coordinate together?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3908.88,
    "end": 3917.92,
    "text": "To make a decision... Or are they really global rules where it really is a coordination of billions of fungal tips and the fungus is acting like a calculator in many ways."
  },
  {
    "start": 3918.0,
    "end": 3932.82,
    "text": "so There's lots competing hypotheses about how this can work but its' really I think gonna challenge our understanding of cognition and challenge our understanding of information processing in organisms that don't have a central nervous system."
  },
  {
    "start": 3933.3,
    "end": 3940.12,
    "text": "How exciting, and for all what we've learned about these arboscular micro-fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 3941.02,
    "end": 3943.54,
    "text": "Yeah exactly that they appear and disappear!"
  },
  {
    "start": 3943.82,
    "end": 3947.52,
    "text": "Exactly it's going to be difficult but how exciting?"
  },
  {
    "start": 3948.64,
    "end": 3961.88,
    "text": "To close this segment will hear one final brilliant distinction from Professor Hale's unconsciousness and cognition And whether she herself believes fungi possess any cognitive capabilities."
  },
  {
    "start": 3965.22,
    "end": 3970.4,
    "text": "The uncoupling of consciousness with cognition is a crucial move."
  },
  {
    "start": 3970.56,
    "end": 3984.52,
    "text": "That's really the point in the unthought book, to argue that consciousness isn't just the whole of cognition but only a small part of it even in humans and non-human organisms."
  },
  {
    "start": 3985.66,
    "end": 3997.02,
    "text": "The fact they are not conscious for example trees or fungi or bacteria does not mean that they do not have cognitive capabilities."
  },
  {
    "start": 3997.14,
    "end": 3997.52,
    "text": "In fact,"
  },
  {
    "start": 4014.86,
    "end": 4027.8,
    "text": "What do"
  },
  {
    "start": 4041.46,
    "end": 4047.84,
    "text": "you see as the three most important strategies fungi and plants use to keep these markets going?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4048.36,
    "end": 4050.2,
    "text": "I can't believe your gonna make me name three."
  },
  {
    "start": 4051.6,
    "end": 4056.28,
    "text": "We'll go with other kind of dynamics where we will have a lot room"
  },
  {
    "start": 4056.64,
    "end": 4057.52,
    "text": "To talk about them."
  },
  {
    "start": 4057.56,
    "end": 4058.62,
    "text": "Yeah, it's a great question."
  },
  {
    "start": 4058.7,
    "end": 4059.3,
    "text": "I mean what three?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4060.72,
    "end": 4082.74,
    "text": "I think um i would choose the idea that the fungi avoid trading with plants that are growing in the shade for example In many cases and experiments That they trade differently depending on how many fungal competitors Are present that They can artificially inflate The price of the phosphorus by hoarding It in their networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 4087.86,
    "end": 4090.36,
    "text": "All of them require more investigation."
  },
  {
    "start": 4090.46,
    "end": 4094.06,
    "text": "Again, I wish so many more labs were working on this that we could all compare notes."
  },
  {
    "start": 4094.76,
    "end": 4106.54,
    "text": "but what we're discovering is they do these strategies and then a lot times are trying to understand What the selection pressure leads?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4107.66,
    "end": 4109.14,
    "text": "Is it constantly happening?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4109.96,
    "end": 4119.1,
    "text": "One really important point when talking about strategy Every strategy in and of itself is not going to be a perfect trade deal."
  },
  {
    "start": 4119.859,
    "end": 4122.38,
    "text": "Instead, evolution works on averages."
  },
  {
    "start": 4123.0,
    "end": 4143.5,
    "text": "so if we were to take the average of all these different billions of trade strategies that are happening in space and time... On average both partners would try to maximize their carbon or phosphorus intake but it doesn't mean every single trade decision decision."
  },
  {
    "start": 4144.06,
    "end": 4155.26,
    "text": "And that's really important for sort of understanding what we're seeing in the lab, because many people would point to it and say well no there are obviously times when this happens or when this happened—of course!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4155.34,
    "end": 4156.72,
    "text": "That is the beauty of nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 4157.64,
    "end": 4165.88,
    "text": "What were trying to understand was larger patterns where you see some of these most sophisticated trade strategies emerge."
  },
  {
    "start": 4166.779,
    "end": 4179.68,
    "text": "And Professor Kirsch, you were talking before about these host-imposed control mechanisms in legum risovia symbiosis where poor partners are punished to the extent to be suffocated."
  },
  {
    "start": 4181.06,
    "end": 4184.08,
    "text": "I want ask you – Are generous partners rewarded?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4184.819,
    "end": 4187.74,
    "text": "Jenner's partners are tend to be rewarded."
  },
  {
    "start": 4187.86,
    "end": 4192.76,
    "text": "So those that give more resources, tend to get more resources in return."
  },
  {
    "start": 4193.34,
    "end": 4196.92,
    "text": "but it is interesting again there is this tension and arm race."
  },
  {
    "start": 4197.14,
    "end": 4210.1,
    "text": "so let us take an example a very cooperative mutualist might actually gain the benefit from actively restricting the other partner's ability to obtain resources directly."
  },
  {
    "start": 4210.76,
    "end": 4229.3,
    "text": "So this is very interesting, so if you can imagine a root system that can take up nutrients directly... A really interesting strategy from a fungal point of view is to create a dependence—to actually force that root system to have a dependence on the fungi rather than being able to take it up directly."
  },
  {
    "start": 4229.84,
    "end": 4238.56,
    "text": "and there are for example some hints in that fungi are actually able to down-regulate a plant's own ability, get nutrients."
  },
  {
    "start": 4238.9,
    "end": 4244.58,
    "text": "so it does form more of an addiction on the plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 4246.42,
    "end": 4251.98,
    "text": "It hampers the ability for this partner to survive or reproduce without the help from the fungus."
  },
  {
    "start": 4252.16,
    "end": 4254.78,
    "text": "So I think in all these cases... Yes!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4254.9,
    "end": 4256.6,
    "text": "A generous partner is rewarded."
  },
  {
    "start": 4257.0,
    "end": 4265.42,
    "text": "but then we also have just look harder and there're very clever innovative strategies that change that dynamic."
  },
  {
    "start": 4265.98,
    "end": 4271.44,
    "text": "We look in nature and there are plants that don't photosynthesize at all, you know they're called ghost pipes."
  },
  {
    "start": 4271.58,
    "end": 4280.3,
    "text": "many different kinds of orchids for example have evolved these strategies where they don't waste energy on photosynthecizing their white!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4280.76,
    "end": 4282.2,
    "text": "And yet there's still plants."
  },
  {
    "start": 4282.58,
    "end": 4290.32,
    "text": "what they do is actually tap into a fungal network rather than photosynthesizing themselves."
  },
  {
    "start": 4290.36,
    "end": 4296.92,
    "text": "So in this case, they're a parasite not only on the fungi themselves but onto a green plant nearby."
  },
  {
    "start": 4297.02,
    "end": 4300.44,
    "text": "that is photosynthecising and putting that carbon into the network."
  },
  {
    "start": 4301.02,
    "end": 4301.92,
    "text": "Nature is like that."
  },
  {
    "start": 4302.2,
    "end": 4307.28,
    "text": "I just think it's such a beautiful offer of interactions and really demands."
  },
  {
    "start": 4307.48,
    "end": 4321.18,
    "text": "we take time to look at all these different strategies, not categorize them as generous or mutualistic but try to dig deeper in understanding the tensions that drive innovative strategy within those partnerships."
  },
  {
    "start": 4337.8,
    "end": 4343.74,
    "text": "We like to add a bit of play into the program with quick game-of-short questions and short answers."
  },
  {
    "start": 4344.12,
    "end": 4348.6,
    "text": "And I have few economic, human scenarios... ...and love for you."
  },
  {
    "start": 4348.86,
    "end": 4349.7,
    "text": "translate them in."
  },
  {
    "start": 4349.96,
    "end": 4351.3,
    "text": "what's happening underground!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4351.88,
    "end": 4355.36,
    "text": "If any would require long explanation."
  },
  {
    "start": 4355.58,
    "end": 4358.02,
    "text": "just feel free to say pass Are You Ready?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4358.82,
    "end": 4359.12,
    "text": "I'm ready!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4360.72,
    "end": 4369.3,
    "text": "So In Human Economies credit relies on trust The idea that value can be exchanged now with something returned later."
  },
  {
    "start": 4370.02,
    "end": 4375.4,
    "text": "Do we see any version of that underground, for example to fungi ever extend credit?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4376.02,
    "end": 4379.84,
    "text": "To plants in the sense giving nutrients before they receive carbon?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4381.36,
    "end": 4391.7,
    "text": "Yes, there's definitely evidence that the fungi are first to transfer nutrients into a plant and it may not receive full payoff until the burst of that arboscule."
  },
  {
    "start": 4391.82,
    "end": 4394.82,
    "text": "So...there is time delay but usually pretty short."
  },
  {
    "start": 4396.58,
    "end": 4396.8,
    "text": "Okay!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4396.92,
    "end": 4397.64,
    "text": "The next one."
  },
  {
    "start": 4398.4,
    "end": 4401.52,
    "text": "Undipped and defaulted."
  },
  {
    "start": 4402.26,
    "end": 4405.34,
    "text": "What happens when that balance breaks down?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4405.72,
    "end": 4408.78,
    "text": "Are there cases where plants or fungi fail to pay back?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4409.0,
    "end": 4419.04,
    "text": "Would you have been mentioning already some of that, what they owe and were one partner for example take advantage of the other creating something like ecological debt."
  },
  {
    "start": 4419.78,
    "end": 4427.16,
    "text": "I'm not sure about ecological debt but cheaters definitely cheaters i mean ghost pipes as i said are a perfect example of that."
  },
  {
    "start": 4427.64,
    "end": 4429.64,
    "text": "And these cheaters when their caught?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4430.4,
    "end": 4431.76,
    "text": "how do sanctions look?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4432.2,
    "end": 4433.26,
    "text": "in the underground"
  },
  {
    "start": 4433.94,
    "end": 4435.48,
    "text": "Sanctions are intense."
  },
  {
    "start": 4435.52,
    "end": 4441.44,
    "text": "I mean, that's what i spent a lot of my first half of my career studying was the evolution of sanctions and punishment."
  },
  {
    "start": 4441.54,
    "end": 4446.54,
    "text": "in nature it can be swift It can be severe And it can Be clever!"
  },
  {
    "start": 4447.3,
    "end": 4452.02,
    "text": "So yes some forms it takes of aborting partners."
  },
  {
    "start": 4452.22,
    "end": 4453.74,
    "text": "other case suffocating."
  },
  {
    "start": 4454.02,
    "end": 4456.96,
    "text": "sanctions Are very varied and they're Very intense"
  },
  {
    "start": 4458.46,
    "end": 4459.94,
    "text": "In markets above grounds."
  },
  {
    "start": 4460.04,
    "end": 4461.88,
    "text": "car city drives up prices."
  },
  {
    "start": 4461.98,
    "end": 4463.26,
    "text": "an abundance lowers them."
  },
  {
    "start": 4463.92,
    "end": 4469.82,
    "text": "You've shown similar patterns in fungal trade when phosphorus becomes rare, fungi demand more carbon."
  },
  {
    "start": 4470.64,
    "end": 4475.66,
    "text": "Could we think of that as the kind of biological interest rate or even inflation?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4475.9,
    "end": 4482.24,
    "text": "And what might teach us about how systems both natural and human stabilize themselves under"
  },
  {
    "start": 4482.32,
    "end": 4482.64,
    "text": "stress?\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 4483.42,
    "end": 4488.78,
    "text": "Well I'm not sure it's an interest rate per se... ...I think inflation is more likely."
  },
  {
    "start": 4489.5,
    "end": 4490.66,
    "text": "I think that's a notion."
  },
  {
    "start": 4490.74,
    "end": 4495.24,
    "text": "as old is life itself, the more something is scarce and important."
  },
  {
    "start": 4495.46,
    "end": 4497.32,
    "text": "The more resource it is worth."
  },
  {
    "start": 4497.98,
    "end": 4500.5,
    "text": "but i would say nothing is stable."
  },
  {
    "start": 4500.58,
    "end": 4502.88,
    "text": "its just constant opera of back-and-forth."
  },
  {
    "start": 4515.0,
    "end": 4518.88,
    "text": "Now lets go to macroeconomics and speculation."
  },
  {
    "start": 4519.26,
    "end": 4525.48,
    "text": "Human markets are often driven by speculation Investing energy now in hope for greater return later."
  },
  {
    "start": 4525.9,
    "end": 4527.78,
    "text": "Do fungi ever behave like this?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4528.14,
    "end": 4535.94,
    "text": "For instance, do they invest nutrients in a plant that looks promising as we've heard on the credit even before it can fully repay them?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4537.06,
    "end": 4537.86,
    "text": "It's hard one."
  },
  {
    "start": 4537.94,
    "end": 4545.24,
    "text": "Again because of the time scale for these experiments I think you don't really see long-term"
  },
  {
    "start": 4545.42,
    "end": 4545.94,
    "text": "planning."
  },
  {
    "start": 4546.58,
    "end": 4550.06,
    "text": "Also, from an evolutionary vantage point it's hard to imagine."
  },
  {
    "start": 4550.5,
    "end": 4556.04,
    "text": "But we are exploring the concept of memory in Fungi and that still has to be determined."
  },
  {
    "start": 4556.34,
    "end": 4557.64,
    "text": "That is about all I can say for now."
  },
  {
    "start": 4558.56,
    "end": 4565.88,
    "text": "In today's geek economy We see flexible but often precarious exchanges Short-term collaborations without long term security."
  },
  {
    "start": 4566.5,
    "end": 4569.28,
    "text": "Do you see echoes of that underground?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4569.52,
    "end": 4576.24,
    "text": "Are there fungi or plants that act like freelancers forming quick partnerships and moving on when a better offer appears."
  },
  {
    "start": 4577.16,
    "end": 4581.28,
    "text": "Oh yes, again hard to test in the lab but definitely happening in nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 4581.5,
    "end": 4586.98,
    "text": "I mean we see that fungi adopt and adapt all different types of strategy similar."
  },
  {
    "start": 4587.2,
    "end": 4593.28,
    "text": "what plants do let's say after they first colonize a field After disturbance there are some plants get right away."
  },
  {
    "start": 4593.44,
    "end": 4596.62,
    "text": "They're called Ruderal Plants And very good at colonizing fast."
  },
  {
    "start": 4597.22,
    "end": 4598.18,
    "text": "So same thing with Fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 4598.34,
    "end": 4601.34,
    "text": "Some fungus is getting colonized quickly."
  },
  {
    "start": 4601.74,
    "end": 4606.02,
    "text": "There's a real priority order, we think to the way that fungi colonize roots."
  },
  {
    "start": 4606.74,
    "end": 4614.08,
    "text": "And again there is lots of learning in nature and In the lab you can just set up very simple experiments To test this idea."
  },
  {
    "start": 4614.72,
    "end": 4621.02,
    "text": "Well The global economy depends on vast trade routes Shipping exchange sometimes exploitation."
  },
  {
    "start": 4621.6,
    "end": 4625.52,
    "text": "The micro-risal networks also connect distant partners across systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 4626.16,
    "end": 4634.66,
    "text": "Would you say they operate more like fur trade cooperatives or like empires where certain fungi dominate the flow of resources?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4635.16,
    "end": 4641.64,
    "text": "Yeah, we definitely liken them more to local bartering rather than a vast global trade that we see as humans."
  },
  {
    "start": 4641.74,
    "end": 4648.06,
    "text": "I mean it's still unknown exactly how large individual networks can grow too—it's really hard to study in nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 4648.46,
    "end": 4651.72,
    "text": "but what we do know is they're operating locally."
  },
  {
    "start": 4652.38,
    "end": 4657.24,
    "text": "so i would say fair trade cooperatives are very local barter systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 4658.0,
    "end": 4662.58,
    "text": "Nevertheless, it seemed to be many examples of inequalities emerging underground."
  },
  {
    "start": 4663.66,
    "end": 4664.74,
    "text": "You might say that?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4665.16,
    "end": 4665.6,
    "text": "Of course."
  },
  {
    "start": 4665.9,
    "end": 4672.36,
    "text": "And my question is are there fungal species that monopolize resources To exploit weaker partners?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4672.5,
    "end": 4675.46,
    "text": "and if yes what do you think That teaches about human economies?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4675.58,
    "end": 4678.42,
    "text": "I think all fungi would love to monopolize."
  },
  {
    "start": 4679.2,
    "end": 4683.98,
    "text": "That that would be an ideal strategy in many ways, but life is far too fluid."
  },
  {
    "start": 4684.06,
    "end": 4691.06,
    "text": "it's far too ever-changing and so even just a slight change the environment changes which fungy has an upper hand."
  },
  {
    "start": 4691.58,
    "end": 4693.96,
    "text": "not sure what that says about human economies."
  },
  {
    "start": 4694.08,
    "end": 4696.62,
    "text": "again It's always hard to draw parallels."
  },
  {
    "start": 4697.02,
    "end": 4702.14,
    "text": "But yes i can definitely say that funky do like to monopolized but they don't last very long."
  },
  {
    "start": 4702.34,
    "end": 4705.86,
    "text": "there's Always A new partner thats coming into offer something different."
  },
  {
    "start": 4706.2,
    "end": 4711.32,
    "text": "And I'm curious, you mentioned before seeing powerful decisions in fungi networks happen."
  },
  {
    "start": 4711.58,
    "end": 4715.72,
    "text": "but my question is have you seen them before scarcity shows up?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4716.34,
    "end": 4722.06,
    "text": "Like almost like anticipating it or do these shifts only occur in response to scarcity?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4722.14,
    "end": 4730.06,
    "text": "In other words Do fungi ever relocate resources preemptively Or are their decisions always driven by local shortages?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4730.64,
    "end": 4734.94,
    "text": "I think it's always by local context, but i don't think its' always by the local shortages."
  },
  {
    "start": 4735.44,
    "end": 4736.96,
    "text": "So It could be a local context."
  },
  {
    "start": 4737.14,
    "end": 4753.36,
    "text": "like A new space opens up or A pathogen enters doesn't have to Be about resources or scarcity But The decisions that are made at least That is our hypothesis for now tend To be based on Local Context Rather than preemptive planning."
  },
  {
    "start": 4813.16,
    "end": 4819.98,
    "text": "Bionic and the wires Is an incredible band Based in Manchester formed by John Ross and Andy Kitt."
  },
  {
    "start": 4820.34,
    "end": 4833.22,
    "text": "John is a multidisciplinary artist, technologist an environmental thinker And the founder and CEO of So The City A non-profit environmental organization whose work challenges human centric views of creativity."
  },
  {
    "start": 4834.24,
    "end": 4836.88,
    "text": "His divisionary behind the bands groundbreaking setups."
  },
  {
    "start": 4837.76,
    "end": 4842.0,
    "text": "Well Andy he's the sonic sorceror who brings uh...the sound of roll."
  },
  {
    "start": 4842.26,
    "end": 4848.36,
    "text": "biosignals brought to life through synthesizers keyboards and digital soundscapes."
  },
  {
    "start": 4848.98,
    "end": 4858.44,
    "text": "Together they explored intelligence, and responsiveness of the natural world through bio-electrical signals that are translated into artistic expressions like the melody."
  },
  {
    "start": 4858.86,
    "end": 4863.9,
    "text": "we're now hearing in the background a mushroom in the wild playing the keyboard."
  },
  {
    "start": 4864.64,
    "end": 4868.44,
    "text": "And here is John Ross with A Couple Of Questions for You."
  },
  {
    "start": 4870.28,
    "end": 4871.4,
    "text": "Hi my name's John Ross."
  },
  {
    "start": 4872.16,
    "end": 4873.36,
    "text": "I'm from Bionic In The Wires."
  },
  {
    "start": 4874.08,
    "end": 4879.66,
    "text": "We're Manchester UK-based bioartists that connect bionic arms to fungi so they can make music."
  },
  {
    "start": 4880.84,
    "end": 4889.24,
    "text": "Millions of people have watched our videos online and the question a lot of viewers ask us is whether fungi can hear their music, we are helping them create."
  },
  {
    "start": 4890.0,
    "end": 4890.94,
    "text": "Do you think it's possible?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4891.54,
    "end": 4895.1,
    "text": "And what frequencies do you think they would respond or even enjoy?"
  },
  {
    "start": 4897.78,
    "end": 4898.88,
    "text": "So mycorrhizal fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 4899.68,
    "end": 4910.84,
    "text": "know I'm exquisitely sensitive When we think about can fungi hear music, what we're talking about is actually vibration."
  },
  {
    "start": 4911.72,
    "end": 4918.32,
    "text": "And we do think that at least the fungi underground that we study are very sensitive to vibrations."
  },
  {
    "start": 4918.8,
    "end": 4927.3,
    "text": "and again this is something that were working on right now really trying understand how vibrations affect flow patterns inside these networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 4928.16,
    "end": 4929.62,
    "text": "Soils are complex."
  },
  {
    "start": 4929.76,
    "end": 4943.7,
    "text": "I cannot say it again, It is incredible what they're exposed to really, really bathing in all kinds of different frequencies and vibrations And so that's something we explore in the lab."
  },
  {
    "start": 4944.36,
    "end": 4951.44,
    "text": "You have to do very precisely Because you can actually look at flows real-time."
  },
  {
    "start": 4952.0,
    "end": 4960.76,
    "text": "We can expose them to different frequencies See how those flow patterns change And so in many ways, this is sometimes I liken to what we do."
  },
  {
    "start": 4961.24,
    "end": 4966.1,
    "text": "To actually being a little bit like primatologists just observing primates in nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 4966.2,
    "end": 4972.12,
    "text": "So we can set up all kinds of treatments Like different vibrations and then see how they respond."
  },
  {
    "start": 4972.78,
    "end": 4975.08,
    "text": "That's something that we are actively working on right now."
  },
  {
    "start": 4975.72,
    "end": 4988.98,
    "text": "Talking about emotions and feelings Let us listen to ecologist Carl Zafina one last time On what he believes to be the most basic feeling In living things Followed by his answer to the question you formulated for him."
  },
  {
    "start": 4989.46,
    "end": 5012.26,
    "text": "If you could imagine, The first kind of creature that might have felt anything at all So try to imagine something like a worm on the seabed in some ancient sea A billion years ago And it might be the first thing That can feel anything At all."
  },
  {
    "start": 5013.2,
    "end": 5015.12,
    "text": "What does It need To Feel?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5015.84,
    "end": 5020.06,
    "text": "probably needs to feel if it has just bumped into some food."
  },
  {
    "start": 5020.68,
    "end": 5043.82,
    "text": "So, If It Bumps Into Mud Or Stones the most basic feeling would be no and if it bumps into Food The Most Basic Feeling Would Be Yeah That Is An Aesthetic Judgment Its Positive Versus Negative its Good Versus Bad And so it Would Prefer what seems good and feels good, right?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5043.88,
    "end": 5053.18,
    "text": "So I actually think that detecting something... ...and perceiving it as good which is very much adjacent to beautiful."
  },
  {
    "start": 5054.28,
    "end": 5061.4,
    "text": "And makes you want to be near in the same kind of way-I think that's most basic feeling In living things."
  },
  {
    "start": 5061.74,
    "end": 5068.88,
    "text": "Some people insist every cell can feel.. ..And some people insist nothing without a brain Can Feel."
  },
  {
    "start": 5069.64,
    "end": 5070.7,
    "text": "Do fungi feel?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5070.8,
    "end": 5071.66,
    "text": "That's our question."
  },
  {
    "start": 5072.34,
    "end": 5072.86,
    "text": "I don't know."
  },
  {
    "start": 5073.44,
    "end": 5088.38,
    "text": "the short answer is no one knows and there's No consensus about it, but i will say this These questions are not simple yes or no Questions About One Thing Called Feeling."
  },
  {
    "start": 5088.58,
    "end": 5102.84,
    "text": "I think that to try To get at This you have to chop The Stages Into Little Bits And one stage is processing information."
  },
  {
    "start": 5103.14,
    "end": 5107.44,
    "text": "So, first of all every cell Is incredibly complex."
  },
  {
    "start": 5108.58,
    "end": 5112.22,
    "text": "It's not just a little bag of fluid with a nucleus in it and some DNA."
  },
  {
    "start": 5112.72,
    "end": 5120.66,
    "text": "Its an incredibly complex place With thousands and thousands Of chemical reactions going on All the time."
  },
  {
    "start": 5121.24,
    "end": 5133.38,
    "text": "The membrane of every cell Has numerous sensing ports that react to chemicals around it, and in that way its senses the environment."
  },
  {
    "start": 5133.46,
    "end": 5135.56,
    "text": "I'm not saying it feels the environment."
  },
  {
    "start": 5135.6,
    "end": 5141.34,
    "text": "but if you think of like a motion sensor or thermostat they sense and respond."
  },
  {
    "start": 5141.92,
    "end": 5151.24,
    "text": "basic cognition which is unconscious cognition senses evaluates and responds."
  },
  {
    "start": 5151.72,
    "end": 5156.14,
    "text": "all this might be chemical reactions with no feeling."
  },
  {
    "start": 5156.6,
    "end": 5171.94,
    "text": "but every cell is capable of sensing, evaluating and responding because that's how they can maintain themselves as alive without just falling apart in the world of entropy... ...and randomness."
  },
  {
    "start": 5172.82,
    "end": 5177.36,
    "text": "So the question is at what stage do they feel that?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5177.78,
    "end": 5183.48,
    "text": "But fungus are very complicated And they clearly communicate."
  },
  {
    "start": 5184.32,
    "end": 5189.08,
    "text": "but a lot of things that are not conscious communicate, our computers communicate."
  },
  {
    "start": 5189.58,
    "end": 5191.88,
    "text": "But that doesn't mean it's conscious."
  },
  {
    "start": 5192.5,
    "end": 5192.56,
    "text": "so"
  },
  {
    "start": 5193.56,
    "end": 5198.56,
    "text": "I think uh...it is clear that fungi are extremely complex."
  },
  {
    "start": 5199.2,
    "end": 5201.2,
    "text": "It's clear they communicate alot."
  },
  {
    "start": 5202.08,
    "end": 5203.18,
    "text": "i don't know if their conscious?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5203.9,
    "end": 5206.26,
    "text": "I would love to know what she thinks about the question."
  },
  {
    "start": 5207.08,
    "end": 5209.64,
    "text": "So Professor Toby Kears What do you say?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5210.58,
    "end": 5211.0,
    "text": "Wow,"
  },
  {
    "start": 5211.48,
    "end": 5211.9,
    "text": "wow."
  },
  {
    "start": 5212.42,
    "end": 5213.28,
    "text": "It's quite hard."
  },
  {
    "start": 5213.44,
    "end": 5213.64,
    "text": "I mean."
  },
  {
    "start": 5213.74,
    "end": 5227.66,
    "text": "using the word consciousness is difficult i think and that's why always try to take it back To what we can see in What We Can Measure Because The Jury Is Out And Im Open To Finding New Things."
  },
  {
    "start": 5227.76,
    "end": 5232.42,
    "text": "I Think That'S Really Important In Sciences That It Doesn'T Become Dogmatic."
  },
  {
    "start": 5232.52,
    "end": 5237.32,
    "text": "We Have Nothing To Prove In Terms Of Understanding If Fungi Are Conscious Or Not."
  },
  {
    "start": 5237.86,
    "end": 5240.18,
    "text": "we just want to explore their inner lives."
  },
  {
    "start": 5240.72,
    "end": 5258.68,
    "text": "And so that's my job, is sort of work together with this incredible biophysics lab to probe the inner lives of fungi and come up with clever experiments that allow us to probe that world in a very respectful way... ...and follow it very precisely!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5259.36,
    "end": 5273.08,
    "text": "Again I've come back into these flow patterns inside the fungi High dimensional information So much information inside that network, that we can start to capture of individual particles moving through it."
  },
  {
    "start": 5273.82,
    "end": 5276.58,
    "text": "Trying to make sense of that is very hard."
  },
  {
    "start": 5276.66,
    "end": 5284.74,
    "text": "I mean obviously We use a lot with machine learning algorithms To try and process what we're seeing but we don't even know if were asking the right questions."
  },
  {
    "start": 5285.26,
    "end": 5308.2,
    "text": "That's kind of you know getting terabytes data on month This really big new field of trying to ask question almost in bottom up not doing experiments where you set it up and that you sort of know the hypothesis of what your testing ahead-of time, but really probing an inner life is a different kind of scientific method than we're all just starting to explore."
  },
  {
    "start": 5309.14,
    "end": 5318.9,
    "text": "What I can say is when people come into the lab and they interact with the fungi which they can do in realtime...I think that surprises people!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5319.26,
    "end": 5325.76,
    "text": "We actually go tag the carbon with this fluorescent, beautiful label."
  },
  {
    "start": 5326.42,
    "end": 5336.38,
    "text": "We can take off the Petri plate and we can just blow on the fungi...we can talk to the fungi…and our breath changes the direction of the flows inside it!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5336.94,
    "end": 5344.6,
    "text": "We can interact in a time scale—on OUR timescale– and sort-of probe it into ways that we can see in realtime."
  },
  {
    "start": 5345.14,
    "end": 5347.98,
    "text": "And when people do that, that changes their way."
  },
  {
    "start": 5348.36,
    "end": 5350.06,
    "text": "they SEE fungi I think."
  },
  {
    "start": 5350.7,
    "end": 5357.6,
    "text": "And, you know the fact that they're much closely related to animals than they are to plants is quite interesting."
  },
  {
    "start": 5358.04,
    "end": 5360.9,
    "text": "There's just a lot right on the edges of discovery."
  },
  {
    "start": 5361.24,
    "end": 5375.26,
    "text": "I think the next kind of ten-to-twenty years we're going to really use science and use different methods of questioning the world to figure out a lot more about fungi... ...and maybe even our own consciousness"
  },
  {
    "start": 5375.64,
    "end": 5376.28,
    "text": "Absolutely."
  },
  {
    "start": 5377.14,
    "end": 5388.92,
    "text": "To close this segment, we'll hear one final brilliant distinction from Professor Hale's unconsciousness cognition and whether she believes fungi possesses any cognitive capabilities."
  },
  {
    "start": 5389.96,
    "end": 5395.14,
    "text": "The uncoupling of consciousness with cognition is a crucial move."
  },
  {
    "start": 5395.3,
    "end": 5404.48,
    "text": "That's really the point in the unthought book, to argue that Consciousness isn't just the whole of Cognition it's only a small part."
  },
  {
    "start": 5405.5,
    "end": 5421.76,
    "text": "even in humans and non-human organisms The fact they are not conscious for example trees or fungi or bacteria does not mean that they do not have cognitive capabilities."
  },
  {
    "start": 5421.86,
    "end": 5422.44,
    "text": "In fact, they"
  },
  {
    "start": 5422.56,
    "end": 5422.64,
    "text": "do.\"."
  },
  {
    "start": 5428.24,
    "end": 5430.96,
    "text": "Well all I know is that beneath our force."
  },
  {
    "start": 5431.04,
    "end": 5434.94,
    "text": "there's no central command center—no brain pulling the strings."
  },
  {
    "start": 5435.22,
    "end": 5441.36,
    "text": "yet we've learned through all you share with us today this remarkable."
  },
  {
    "start": 5441.44,
    "end": 5447.72,
    "text": "fungal networks link roots move nutrients and distribute carbon and nitrogen across the soil."
  },
  {
    "start": 5448.38,
    "end": 5455.16,
    "text": "We also that animals like ants and bears contribute minerals and nutrients, that enter these underground systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 5456.02,
    "end": 5464.04,
    "text": "And we also learn how the fungi protect plants from plastic and from metals in such a decentralized setup."
  },
  {
    "start": 5464.4,
    "end": 5470.04,
    "text": "We've talked about how competitive this fungal networks are thriving for reproduction and survival."
  },
  {
    "start": 5470.1,
    "end": 5486.8,
    "text": "But I ask myself if you think about ancestral evolutionary knowledge Could we see these fungal networks as a kind of equalizer distributing resources across the system, and could they be thought as sort of collective memory?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5487.06,
    "end": 5491.44,
    "text": "A living archive in the past that shaped how resources move today."
  },
  {
    "start": 5492.34,
    "end": 5498.44,
    "text": "We work with cultures and local communities all over the world."
  },
  {
    "start": 5498.82,
    "end": 5517.98,
    "text": "Through my work with SPUN, which stands for The Society For The Protection Of Underground Networks we are developing this new sort of way-of doing science in a very decentralized way where we work people around the world to understand fungal networks, these mycorrhizal networks in their own habitats."
  },
  {
    "start": 5518.2,
    "end": 5524.64,
    "text": "And I had the opportunity to travel to Ecuador and work with the Seriaku people together."
  },
  {
    "start": 5525.66,
    "end": 5530.92,
    "text": "a moth project so Moth stands for more than human life project coming out of NYU Law."
  },
  {
    "start": 5531.74,
    "end": 5536.78,
    "text": "We were able talk members of the seriaku community about fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 5537.38,
    "end": 5545.98,
    "text": "what happens underground actually show them videos carbon-labeled traveling through the network."
  },
  {
    "start": 5546.52,
    "end": 5550.9,
    "text": "And I'll always remember some of the responses, well off course this is happening!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5550.98,
    "end": 5552.1,
    "text": "We knew that it's part."
  },
  {
    "start": 5552.28,
    "end": 5561.94,
    "text": "our belief and understanding about living forest And bringing in that different type of knowledge system, I think is really critical."
  },
  {
    "start": 5562.78,
    "end": 5570.1,
    "text": "That's what's happening right now as scientists are being more open to different knowledge systems—different ways of seeing the world."
  },
  {
    "start": 5570.7,
    "end": 5573.86,
    "text": "and it's important science is inherently creative."
  },
  {
    "start": 5574.5,
    "end": 5579.86,
    "text": "getting out there understanding different ways looking at the world is essential for these systems."
  },
  {
    "start": 5580.48,
    "end": 5583.8,
    "text": "So again, it's not something that I can say yes or no to."
  },
  {
    "start": 5584.4,
    "end": 5587.7,
    "text": "It is only that I am open for different interpretations."
  },
  {
    "start": 5588.28,
    "end": 5601.28,
    "text": "Well i'm glad you mentioned SPON which is an organization that not only protects fungal networks but also maps them connects people around the world as said and brings this underground universe into global awareness."
  },
  {
    "start": 5601.94,
    "end": 5610.38,
    "text": "because our very last question we are going travel to Panama a place where I know opened the door for you into this magical world."
  },
  {
    "start": 5611.12,
    "end": 5616.2,
    "text": "After a long day in the fields, we are closing with a nice dinner on a nice garden."
  },
  {
    "start": 5616.88,
    "end": 5619.22,
    "text": "In front of us there's gorgeous lemon tree."
  },
  {
    "start": 5619.88,
    "end": 5628.82,
    "text": "We get lost our thoughts and suddenly words of beautiful unpretentious poem by Jennifer Clements seem to drift into our minds."
  },
  {
    "start": 5629.74,
    "end": 5642.6,
    "text": "Lemon Tree If You Climb A Lemon Tree Fell at Spark with your feet and knees, smell its white flowers rub in your hands it's leaves."
  },
  {
    "start": 5643.86,
    "end": 5651.8,
    "text": "Remember the tree is older than you And In Its Branches You might find stories."
  },
  {
    "start": 5669.16,
    "end": 5679.7,
    "text": "times, Toby if someone had told you in those early days in Panama that you would one day will create the first Atlas of The Underground."
  },
  {
    "start": 5680.04,
    "end": 5681.38,
    "text": "Will you have believed it?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5683.58,
    "end": 5686.559,
    "text": "It's so wonderful and how dramatic."
  },
  {
    "start": 5688.74,
    "end": 5691.32,
    "text": "I also want to stress that this is just the beginning."
  },
  {
    "start": 5691.42,
    "end": 5699.7,
    "text": "Like, you know we were able to publish what we call The Underground Atlas and it was an a major achievement but its still just beginning!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5700.2,
    "end": 5701.88,
    "text": "It's like point zero-zero."
  },
  {
    "start": 5702.059,
    "end": 5706.16,
    "text": "one percent of the pixels on earth have been sampled from my Greisel Fungi there."
  },
  {
    "start": 5706.32,
    "end": 5708.059,
    "text": "so much, SO MUCH TO DO."
  },
  {
    "start": 5709.28,
    "end": 5711.58,
    "text": "that book isn't closed in that chapter."
  },
  {
    "start": 5712.24,
    "end": 5723.26,
    "text": "But i think even a decade ago Sort of creating a blueprint for the Earth's living underground fungal communities would have seemed impossible."
  },
  {
    "start": 5723.86,
    "end": 5741.559,
    "text": "And when I was in Panama, really like our tools and understandings they generally had been confined to their earth surface not so much about what is happening below ground with these emerging techniques including machine learning and fungal sequencing and robotics that we can."
  },
  {
    "start": 5742.059,
    "end": 5743.72,
    "text": "Yeah, we can start to work with fungi."
  },
  {
    "start": 5744.04,
    "end": 5749.38,
    "text": "To change the trajectory of I think some of the biodiversity and climate crises."
  },
  {
    "start": 5749.5,
    "end": 5751.4,
    "text": "And that's what SPUN is about."
  },
  {
    "start": 5751.52,
    "end": 5763.02,
    "text": "It's about bringing together a network Of people around the world Um...to actually go out and sample fungi In some of most remote hard-to-access ecosystems on Earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 5764.08,
    "end": 5775.52,
    "text": "Bring those invisible networks to life, show who is where and really start to kind of chart an atlas so we can protect these very important fungal communities below ground."
  },
  {
    "start": 5775.86,
    "end": 5777.66,
    "text": "Well you've come a long way."
  },
  {
    "start": 5777.98,
    "end": 5787.32,
    "text": "today in the morning I just read that protection off fungal network's going be included in the UK's environmental policy."
  },
  {
    "start": 5787.66,
    "end": 5795.62,
    "text": "This is huge news, this is really an exciting day for Fungi Foundation and Juliana Forci who has been leading this work."
  },
  {
    "start": 5797.559,
    "end": 5798.28,
    "text": "incredible"
  },
  {
    "start": 5798.4,
    "end": 5803.28,
    "text": "changes are happening I think both at national level and international levels for the protections of Funghi."
  },
  {
    "start": 5803.38,
    "end": 5808.2,
    "text": "a lot that she had done with Fungifoundation made it possible."
  },
  {
    "start": 5808.639,
    "end": 5809.66,
    "text": "so we're all celebrating."
  },
  {
    "start": 5810.3,
    "end": 5825.82,
    "text": "You know, hearing about all of this you make me think also off how the Earth is a living interconnected organism and that life exists not only above ground in forests and oceans but it's also in the microscopic worlds that sustain them."
  },
  {
    "start": 5826.1,
    "end": 5827.76,
    "text": "And I think this is awesome!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5828.72,
    "end": 5834.36,
    "text": "My last question...is Toby when you imagine the future of spun."
  },
  {
    "start": 5834.88,
    "end": 5835.6,
    "text": "what do you see?"
  },
  {
    "start": 5836.16,
    "end": 5837.8,
    "text": "Well, we want to do norm-shifting."
  },
  {
    "start": 5837.96,
    "end": 5844.36,
    "text": "I mean...I think people assume that soils are dead and inert And thats because soil life is largely invisible."
  },
  {
    "start": 5844.84,
    "end": 5855.2,
    "text": "But We started using the term underground astronaut To describe our work Because we want people to understand That this IS as vast a frontier As above their heads!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5856.18,
    "end": 5859.86,
    "text": "The biggest challenge has really been for People to flip their perspectives."
  },
  {
    "start": 5860.639,
    "end": 5864.12,
    "text": "Think about underground ecosystems as where Life begins."
  },
  {
    "start": 5864.92,
    "end": 5870.639,
    "text": "So this future, I mean if we're serious about protecting biodiversity that means biodiversity below ground."
  },
  {
    "start": 5871.18,
    "end": 5873.28,
    "text": "It must include life underground."
  },
  {
    "start": 5873.9,
    "end": 5875.32,
    "text": "so thats what the future looks like."
  },
  {
    "start": 5875.36,
    "end": 5877.04,
    "text": "it's about making people curious."
  },
  {
    "start": 5877.66,
    "end": 5881.78,
    "text": "its about imagining fungal networks and exploring their inner lives in behavior."
  },
  {
    "start": 5882.42,
    "end": 5886.1,
    "text": "And really the future is about making peoples see the underground differently."
  },
  {
    "start": 5904.88,
    "end": 5919.12,
    "text": "Well Professor Tobi Kiers I think that the kind of consciousness you create is that of an astronaut who travels thousands of kilometers to discover new universes, only to realize everything and everyone is connected."
  },
  {
    "start": 5919.68,
    "end": 5923.08,
    "text": "And we are responsible for those connections as we become aware of them."
  },
  {
    "start": 5923.94,
    "end": 5939.22,
    "text": "Thank You For Contributing To Planetary Science And Helping Us See The Unseen Systems That Support All Life Including Of Course Our Own Your Creative Energy And discovering is both joyful and essential to awakening our society."
  },
  {
    "start": 5939.84,
    "end": 5944.54,
    "text": "Thank you so much for giving us your time today, and an amazing interview!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5945.1,
    "end": 5949.54,
    "text": "It's been such a pleasure being on this journey with you... ...and Go Fungi!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5951.02,
    "end": 5952.44,
    "text": "Thank you all of the listeners."
  },
  {
    "start": 5952.54,
    "end": 5966.92,
    "text": "wherever you are allowing us to spend some more time with you You would like find out about the exciting research by Professor Kier's lab including papers and upcoming projects, please visit her website at www.topicures.com."
  },
  {
    "start": 5967.24,
    "end": 5973.32,
    "text": "for more information about SPUN which is dedicated to mapping & protecting the Earth's underground fungal networks."
  },
  {
    "start": 5973.76,
    "end": 5974.88,
    "text": "go to spun.earth."
  },
  {
    "start": 5975.66,
    "end": 5979.34,
    "text": "For social media Go To Spun Underground And Spun.Youth."
  },
  {
    "start": 5980.32,
    "end": 5985.88,
    "text": "And last but not least, for all references including papers published by Professor Tobi Kier's lab in Nature."
  },
  {
    "start": 5986.48,
    "end": 5990.72,
    "text": "For more information discussed during this interview check out the episode description."
  },
  {
    "start": 5991.24,
    "end": 5991.58,
    "text": "Thank you!"
  },
  {
    "start": 5991.9,
    "end": 5993.26,
    "text": "Bye-bye."
  }
]