WEBVTT

00:00:00.150 --> 00:00:02.150
Here's a hot take, and I'll explain it.

00:00:02.483 --> 00:00:06.403
I think we humans think that we like

00:00:06.403 --> 00:00:09.020
content that was generated by humans,

00:00:09.100 --> 00:00:12.220
that we prefer that over
AI-generated content,

00:00:12.550 --> 00:00:16.070
but I think that is increasingly wrong.

00:00:16.150 --> 00:00:20.630
And I'll explain it before you
start flaming me. But I had this

00:00:20.710 --> 00:00:24.010
thought for the last couple of
weeks and months, to be honest, and

00:00:24.150 --> 00:00:27.110
then I encountered this
post here by Tim Sweeney,

00:00:27.110 --> 00:00:32.070
the founder and majority owner
of Epic, the CEO of Epic Games,

00:00:32.470 --> 00:00:37.110
who recently posted on X. We have a
huge pivot underway here at Epic,

00:00:37.350 --> 00:00:41.750
moving developers around to retool
for maximum AI acceleration.

00:00:42.168 --> 00:00:45.608
The aim isn't to do the same
stuff with fewer people,

00:00:45.928 --> 00:00:50.008
but to enable everyone here to build
more and better stuff, and to bring

00:00:50.008 --> 00:00:54.808
the benefits to all teams using
Unreal, the Unreal Engine, that is.

00:00:55.150 --> 00:00:58.110
Now, naturally, DHH was
quite happy about that,

00:00:58.450 --> 00:01:03.010
and I also agree here.
But this is, in the end,

00:01:03.250 --> 00:01:05.570
you could say a relatively
standard statement, right?

00:01:05.570 --> 00:01:08.290
A lot of companies are embracing AI.

00:01:08.290 --> 00:01:13.250
I think a lot of layoffs
have been announced

00:01:13.410 --> 00:01:17.810
due to AI, and obviously, that is
a bad thing and not what I like.

00:01:18.150 --> 00:01:20.790
But what's interesting about this
statement, therefore, well, for one,

00:01:20.790 --> 00:01:23.990
especially that it's not
about layoffs, but also that

00:01:24.317 --> 00:01:27.597
it's from a company, a games
company, which is of course

00:01:27.597 --> 00:01:32.557
all about creativity and the
content, the games they build,

00:01:33.117 --> 00:01:37.117
and naturally, one of the
most popular reactions here

00:01:37.450 --> 00:01:41.290
is this one at least for
me when I view this post:

00:01:41.770 --> 00:01:46.570
If Unreal becomes an engine where
you upload a few pages outlining

00:01:46.570 --> 00:01:50.650
a game idea, and five minutes
later you get a fully playable AAA

00:01:50.650 --> 00:01:54.570
fidelity game, do you think this
would be a good thing for humanity?

00:01:54.570 --> 00:01:57.050
And obviously, this is a
pretty critical comment.

00:01:57.450 --> 00:02:01.210
And there are more comments
like this now. For one,

00:02:01.690 --> 00:02:06.416
in his post, it's not about giving
you something where you just upload

00:02:06.416 --> 00:02:10.816
a draft and get a finished game, but
clearly, of course, the goal is to

00:02:11.296 --> 00:02:15.616
develop the Unreal Engine into a
direction where you can use it,

00:02:15.616 --> 00:02:19.456
for example, to vibe code games,
if you want to put it like this.

00:02:19.456 --> 00:02:23.216
And you can absolutely discuss
whether these would be

00:02:23.216 --> 00:02:25.983
the games you want to play or
not. But here's the thing.

00:02:26.017 --> 00:02:28.657
As I mentioned at the very
beginning, I think we humans like

00:02:28.657 --> 00:02:31.937
to think that we want to consume content,

00:02:32.177 --> 00:02:34.417
no matter which content—if that's videos,

00:02:34.417 --> 00:02:38.497
if that's games, if that's
movies, text, music,

00:02:38.817 --> 00:02:42.417
created by other humans—and
I would have agreed to

00:02:42.497 --> 00:02:46.257
that statement until a couple
of months ago, at least.

00:02:46.657 --> 00:02:49.537
And I'm still not sure
if I entirely disagree,

00:02:49.537 --> 00:02:54.449
but I think that we
overestimate how important this

00:02:54.449 --> 00:02:58.689
really is to us humans, and of
course, just to be very clear here,

00:02:59.017 --> 00:03:02.377
that is not a general thing
for you. It may be one hundred

00:03:02.377 --> 00:03:06.857
percent clear that you want human
content only, and that is fine.

00:03:07.183 --> 00:03:10.303
I just think that throughout the ages,

00:03:10.650 --> 00:03:14.250
how things are built and
who builds something has

00:03:14.250 --> 00:03:18.170
changed so many times that
it's pretty dangerous

00:03:18.517 --> 00:03:23.157
to keep a hard opinion on this AI content

00:03:23.237 --> 00:03:27.397
thing, for example, you
may have said, let's say,

00:03:27.717 --> 00:03:28.917
150 years ago,

00:03:29.250 --> 00:03:30.930
that you, or 100 years ago,

00:03:30.930 --> 00:03:35.730
even that you absolutely only
want to wear clothing created

00:03:36.210 --> 00:03:40.450
by a craftsman who really
knows their craft,

00:03:40.690 --> 00:03:43.730
handcrafted in your country,
maybe in your city.

00:03:44.050 --> 00:03:45.890
You want to have shoes that were

00:03:45.970 --> 00:03:49.090
created by an artisan in your city.

00:03:49.417 --> 00:03:52.057
Nowadays, we buy whatever is cheapest,

00:03:52.057 --> 00:03:56.457
or most people buy what's cheapest,
or at least which brand they want,

00:03:56.697 --> 00:04:00.777
and they don't care if it's
manufactured in China, Bangladesh,

00:04:01.123 --> 00:04:04.403
Italy or somewhere else. Some
people care, one hundred percent.

00:04:04.483 --> 00:04:06.883
Some people care and they pay a premium,

00:04:07.203 --> 00:04:09.803
but of course not everybody
can afford that premium.

00:04:09.843 --> 00:04:12.963
A lot of people don't
care or can't afford it.

00:04:13.283 --> 00:04:15.923
And you can have philosophical
discussions about this:

00:04:15.923 --> 00:04:19.683
Is this a good thing? Would they
care if they could afford it?

00:04:19.683 --> 00:04:23.763
Maybe. I just think that with
AI, it's kind of similar.

00:04:24.083 --> 00:04:27.443
And for example, if we take text,
which obviously was the first

00:04:27.443 --> 00:04:31.763
form of AI that entered the mainstream
with the release of ChatGPT,

00:04:32.243 --> 00:04:36.723
it's probably fair to assume
that a huge chunk of text we

00:04:36.723 --> 00:04:40.243
consume these days, at least
on the internet, but also

00:04:40.243 --> 00:04:42.093
outside of the internet increasingly,

00:04:42.350 --> 00:04:44.590
is AI-generated or at least,

00:04:44.917 --> 00:04:47.557
to huge parts AI-generated.

00:04:48.037 --> 00:04:51.797
If you're reading a newspaper
article where the first draft was

00:04:52.037 --> 00:04:55.637
created by an AI and which was
then polished up by a human,

00:04:56.037 --> 00:04:58.677
is that human generated?
Is it AI-generated?

00:04:59.157 --> 00:05:01.077
You can make both arguments here.

00:05:01.417 --> 00:05:04.777
And I would definitely make
the argument that if a human

00:05:05.017 --> 00:05:09.817
put a lot of thought and
effort into having the AI

00:05:09.817 --> 00:05:13.817
generate a great article,
it is a creative product.

00:05:13.817 --> 00:05:17.097
It's a product of that
human, even if AI was used.

00:05:17.417 --> 00:05:21.577
A not perfect example is
that if you're using a word

00:05:21.577 --> 00:05:25.577
processor or a tool like
Microsoft Word for writing,

00:05:25.917 --> 00:05:28.477
obviously it's still written by you,

00:05:28.637 --> 00:05:32.237
even though you did it on a computer.
Now, it's not a perfect example

00:05:32.237 --> 00:05:35.637
because clearly you were typing
every character, but you used a tool

00:05:35.677 --> 00:05:39.597
to help you to format it in a nicer
way to make it more readable.

00:05:39.997 --> 00:05:44.647
You did not write it down by hand.
Again, not a perfect example, I know,

00:05:44.967 --> 00:05:49.927
but AI is just another tool
here—a tool that can help you get

00:05:49.927 --> 00:05:53.607
that draft based on the information
you collected, based on the

00:05:53.687 --> 00:05:56.807
outline you prepared, maybe also
with help of AI. But still,

00:05:57.047 --> 00:06:01.380
it's your creativity and it's your
decisions that go into there. Now,

00:06:01.717 --> 00:06:04.597
obviously, that's not true
for every piece of text.

00:06:04.677 --> 00:06:07.157
There is a lot of slop out there,

00:06:07.483 --> 00:06:11.243
and that probably makes it so hard
to differentiate in many cases.

00:06:11.243 --> 00:06:15.883
With AI, it's super easy
to produce low quality

00:06:15.883 --> 00:06:20.603
products, slop, low quality
text, low quality movies.

00:06:20.950 --> 00:06:25.770
It's super easy. And nobody, I would
guess, likes that, myself included.

00:06:25.770 --> 00:06:28.570
That's not the kind of content
I'm talking about here.

00:06:28.917 --> 00:06:32.437
I'm talking about content generated by

00:06:32.437 --> 00:06:35.557
AI or with help of AI, where, of course,

00:06:35.557 --> 00:06:38.917
you still have the creativity
and the decisions of the humans.

00:06:39.250 --> 00:06:41.650
And I think we need to be more open,

00:06:41.650 --> 00:06:45.890
or simply be prepared for a future
where this will be the norm.

00:06:46.130 --> 00:06:48.770
And now back to this post here by Tim,

00:06:49.330 --> 00:06:54.272
where he turns Epic and
the Unreal Engine into a

00:06:54.272 --> 00:06:58.372
tool that heavily embraces
AI, and as I understand it,

00:06:58.672 --> 00:07:02.832
gives developers that work
with the Unreal Engine tools

00:07:03.072 --> 00:07:06.512
to have an easier time
leveraging AI to build their

00:07:06.512 --> 00:07:10.352
games by building certain AI
features into the engine.

00:07:10.683 --> 00:07:13.003
And I think that's the only way forward.

00:07:13.350 --> 00:07:18.150
We will not have a future
where games are being built

00:07:18.310 --> 00:07:23.190
by people handcrafting 3D models in
Blender, for example. Of course,

00:07:23.190 --> 00:07:26.630
yes, there will be some exceptions
here and there, and they may be

00:07:26.630 --> 00:07:31.339
successful just because of the fact
that they are handcrafted, though.

00:07:31.339 --> 00:07:34.619
If the game sucks, it will
still not be super successful.

00:07:34.939 --> 00:07:39.739
But the majority of games, either
way, will leverage these tools.

00:07:39.739 --> 00:07:44.539
I mean, today already, every
serious game developer and game

00:07:44.539 --> 00:07:49.339
studio is, of course, using AI for
code assistance for generating code,

00:07:49.339 --> 00:07:52.299
like every other developer is
or should be doing at least.

00:07:52.617 --> 00:07:56.377
Of course, that will spill
over to art. Now, again,

00:07:56.377 --> 00:08:00.937
here's the important point: you can
use it to have generic art assets,

00:08:01.017 --> 00:08:03.583
to have slop, to have 3D

00:08:03.583 --> 00:08:07.743
models with lots of little errors.
You can do all that, or you use it

00:08:08.143 --> 00:08:12.863
to turn your creative
vision into prototypes,

00:08:12.863 --> 00:08:16.748
which you can then polish up and
bring into your game. You can

00:08:16.748 --> 00:08:21.388
use it to quickly explore different
art directions by quickly

00:08:21.388 --> 00:08:25.228
spitting out different prototypes
and mockups, just as a developer.

00:08:25.548 --> 00:08:29.708
Where you can also quickly create a
bunch of mockups of a website, and

00:08:29.708 --> 00:08:34.508
then you can see those different
variations and iterate on that.

00:08:34.508 --> 00:08:37.068
You can use it as a tool, but of course,

00:08:37.548 --> 00:08:41.628
the result naturally will be AI-generated,

00:08:41.708 --> 00:08:45.628
since large portions of it are
AI-generated. But it's still

00:08:45.950 --> 00:08:49.710
the artist, the developer,
that poured their knowledge,

00:08:49.790 --> 00:08:53.230
their expertise, and
their decisions into that

00:08:53.230 --> 00:08:56.350
AI usage to get a great result out of it.

00:08:56.683 --> 00:08:59.643
And nowadays, I'm pretty
sure that is what we'll see,

00:08:59.883 --> 00:09:03.083
and what we'll ultimately accept.
What we'll have to accept

00:09:03.417 --> 00:09:06.937
that we'll have music, we'll
have movies, we'll have games,

00:09:06.937 --> 00:09:10.377
we'll obviously have software. We
already have it. We'll have text.

00:09:10.457 --> 00:09:14.217
We already have that too.
All that generated by AI,

00:09:14.457 --> 00:09:17.977
but then we'll have shitty versions,
which are just slop, vibe-coded.

00:09:18.317 --> 00:09:19.997
Which will simply not win

00:09:20.317 --> 00:09:22.237
in the market on the long term,

00:09:22.583 --> 00:09:26.343
and will have great results
where it's not just

00:09:26.503 --> 00:09:29.383
one prompt and let's see
what we get as a result.

00:09:29.717 --> 00:09:31.957
But I think we need to be open to say,

00:09:31.957 --> 00:09:34.197
yeah, it's good that you're using AI.

00:09:34.637 --> 00:09:38.797
Simply for the simple fact that it
allows you to stay in business. If

00:09:38.797 --> 00:09:42.397
you have a favorite game studio and
you want them to stay in business,

00:09:42.717 --> 00:09:46.477
they need to use AI because all
their competitors are moving faster.

00:09:46.877 --> 00:09:50.317
So that alone is a good reason.
But that's not the only reason.

00:09:50.557 --> 00:09:53.197
AI also allows you to be more ambitious,

00:09:53.197 --> 00:09:55.517
and I covered this in
other episodes already.

00:09:55.837 --> 00:09:58.797
But it allows you to
iterate quickly to explore,

00:09:58.797 --> 00:10:01.837
as I mentioned, different
artistic styles, and I think

00:10:02.183 --> 00:10:04.983
these are all the
positive sides we can see

00:10:05.143 --> 00:10:08.023
here when it comes to
AI for art and so on.

00:10:08.350 --> 00:10:09.410
Now, of course, there

00:10:09.410 --> 00:10:13.170
are many things that are
to be criticized about AI,

00:10:13.170 --> 00:10:16.530
or that can be criticized, and
things you can be afraid of.

00:10:16.770 --> 00:10:18.850
Now, for one, for example,
the entire copyright

00:10:18.850 --> 00:10:22.210
thing—how these AI models
were trained and are trained.

00:10:22.772 --> 00:10:25.892
Horrible! Lots of copyright
infringements here.

00:10:26.292 --> 00:10:30.532
At least, I guess that's what many
people, including myself, feel.

00:10:31.092 --> 00:10:34.852
Even though it may not be the
legal side, or there may not

00:10:34.852 --> 00:10:38.292
be a final judgment there, but
obviously that is not great.

00:10:38.617 --> 00:10:40.217
Obviously, you can be afraid.

00:10:40.550 --> 00:10:45.190
We're all feeling this uncertainty
because things are moving so quickly.

00:10:45.517 --> 00:10:49.837
But that does not change that
it's here, and that it can,

00:10:49.837 --> 00:10:53.197
and that it should be leveraged
to build better products.

00:10:53.197 --> 00:10:55.757
And still, right now, we're
in this chaotic phase.

00:10:55.757 --> 00:10:58.717
We have a lot of shitty software,
a lot of shitty products

00:10:58.717 --> 00:11:02.557
because we're still all figuring
out how to use these tools.

00:11:02.637 --> 00:11:05.197
And frankly, because these tools,

00:11:05.517 --> 00:11:08.797
they are becoming much better,
and you can now create

00:11:08.797 --> 00:11:11.243
better results with them
than you could a year ago.

00:11:11.277 --> 00:11:14.077
So combine that with that we're
still all figuring out part,

00:11:14.077 --> 00:11:18.397
and here you are in the current
situation. I'm convinced great products,

00:11:18.397 --> 00:11:20.997
no matter about which kind
of product we're talking,

00:11:21.117 --> 00:11:25.357
will come out because of AI. That
includes all sorts of content,

00:11:25.357 --> 00:11:29.277
including videos. And no, this
does not mean that you will

00:11:29.277 --> 00:11:33.357
only have AI-generated YouTube
videos or something like that.

00:11:33.357 --> 00:11:36.704
But you can have amazing AI-generated

00:11:36.704 --> 00:11:38.864
YouTube videos, which are not the slop.

00:11:39.083 --> 00:11:41.243
You can have amazing AI-generated movies.

00:11:41.483 --> 00:11:43.003
And the slop part,

00:11:43.350 --> 00:11:45.190
I think, will simply lose

00:11:45.407 --> 00:11:46.927
on the global market. So,

00:11:47.250 --> 00:11:50.100
yeah, these are just my two
cents on this topic. I guess.